A Knight's Tale
Mr. Cranky's rating:
One has to figure that writer/producer/director Brian Helgeland actually smoked the research material instead of reading it.
Jousting is a form of 14th-century entertainment in which two idiots with nothing better to do race at each other atop horses and try to knock one another off with big sticks called lances. Essentially, it's the 14th-century version of American Gladiators.Though it's not my intent to play the role of Encyclopedia Britannica, do note that the 14th century was over 600 hundred years ago. So it's just a bit disconcerting when, before the opening match, the crowd starts stomping to the beat of Queen's "We Will Rock You." Okay, fine -- if that's what it takes to get those teenage boys into the theater with their teenage girlfriends who wet their panties like some sort of failed Pavlovian control group at the very sight of Heath Ledger, so be it. However, when the crowd actually starts singing the Queen song, one has to figure that writer/producer/director Brian Helgeland actually smoked the research material instead of reading it.
Though "A Knight's Tale" pretends it's different, the film is basically an amalgam of every clichéd sports film every made. Because William is poor and because only noblemen can fight in the joust, he poses as Sir Ulrich von Lichtenstein of Gelderland and fights in the tournaments. Apparently, nobody bothered checking credentials back then, nor did they have a sense for ridiculous fake names, so anybody could walk around claiming to be noble and attempt to woo noblewomen. In "A Knight's Tale," noblewomen who discover the ruse react with sympathy and utterances of "true love." In the real 14th century, the offender would have been by castrated by a hulking village idiot using a brick.
With just a little practice, William becomes the best jouster ever, presumably because he's poor and has all that heart. Of course, there's the evil Count Adhemar (Rufus Sewell) who's the only other decent jouster in the land and also happens to be wooing the same chick as William, Jocelyn (Shannyn Sossamon). Golly, stop me if you've heard this basic plotline before. Fortunately for William, it's not how large his stick is, but how he uses it. William also has his group of comic relief friends leading him around, including Roland (Mark Addy), Wat (Alan Tudyk) and Geoff Chaucer (Paul Bettany). Naturally, somebody eventually finds out about William's ruse precisely at the wrong moment, and naturally, William and Count Adhemar have a showdown in which William comes back from the brink of defeat to win the day. In the real 14th century, William would have been hauled from the tournament and beaten to death with diseased sheep.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "A Knight's Tale" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "A Knight's Tale" forum
Messages:
jfklhgfhgfh Mr_Cranky
jfklhgfhgfhf Mr_Cranky
jfklhgfhgfhfg Mr_Cranky
jfklhgfhgfhfgh Mr_Cranky
jfklhgfhgfhfghf Mr_Cranky
jfkl Mr_Cranky
jfkls Mr_Cranky
jfklsa Mr_Cranky
jfklsaf Mr_Cranky
jfklsafd Mr_Cranky
You actually preferred this pap to Kiss of the Dragon? okelle
Public Apology to Jessalyn Leyra Karen_G
Bottomsies!!! This forum is mine. DaNcesWithWNdows
I don't care what they say about this movie, I still loved it! moviefreakfromguam
A Knights Tale does have some basis in reality 232013
Knight's Tale? Should be called "Pathetic Garbage" Goob
hey grendude
one grendude
OMG, LIKE, HEATH LEDGER! dizzy37st
Knights tale is a joke politely_rude
Pretty good
Behold, the portal to good, old-fashioned CHRISTIAN PORN! (MAYORBOB)
Fuck the Feds, Vol II... Sonoma County OK's 99 plants per year... (mendo)
100 MOST SHOCKING MOMENTS IN ROCK & ROLL (according to VH1) (Throwing_Muses)
News Flash: FBI Director Admits to Finding McVeigh Documents In His Pants (Mr-Cheeseburger)
No word on whether he yelled "FISH" before he popped it in his mouth. (MAYORBOB)
Catholic School Girls... (mendo)
what i really want to know (mia_wallace)
I paid $1.11 per gallon today... (Homeboy)
Libertarians Delight... from the NYTimes... (mendo)
Is this woman a true Libertarian? (Mr-Cheeseburger)
Gas guzzling SUV riding #1 Democrat Gephardt urges gas conservation. (grundle)
Ha ha! France sucks! Ha ha ha! (grundle)
Another fatal shooting. This time, the killer is a 12-year-old girl. (grundle)
Second batch of McVeigh documents found. (MAYORBOB)
Anyone visited www.maskedloser.com? If not you should! (Masked_Loser)
Energy shortage? What energy shortage? (SavageWombat)
Gene Shalit just chewed this movie up and spat it out on TODAY (Beast)
No, it's not cheese for boobs. (MAYORBOB)
"Lord of the Rings" is pretty much ruling Cannes, by the sounds of things.. (Drew_Atreides)
Here is a very interesting article about fast food. (GTBurns)
Odds of McVeigh taking a permanent nap lengthen further. (Throwing_Muses)
Are you a LOOOOOOSER looking for love? The Perfect Solution! matchmaker make me a (JabBerwoCk)
(Alright motherfuckers, I'm ready) I really liked A Knight's Tale (Dave_Osborne)
"Memento" made it into this week's top 10 (Aron)
The Mummy Returns' Patricia Velasquez on love. (MAYORBOB)
"We are the Knights who say......" (Violet_Beauregarde)
Is Dick Cheyney channelling Dubya? (MAYORBOB)
Knight's Tale review. (0b1knob)
Harry Potter (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
"Man-monkey" triggers panic in suburban New Delhi (Theodoric)
my thoughts on the 12 Bugs Bunny cartoons that Cartoon Network won't air (grundle)
Shit, I missed this for The Mummy Returns forum. (MAYORBOB)
My Annual Summer Rant For All The Dunderheads (BradPhittJr)
Well, I'm no kid. (Throwing_Muses)
Brad: (Morrison_Hotel)
Correcting my omissions (BradPhittJr)
regarding "poorly-written episodes of Nash Bridges." (Bickle)
Unpopular opinion lies within: (Bubbles_Powerpuff)
I'm not a DiCrapio detractor (Aron)
Most summer movies are intended for escapist fun anyhow. (MAYORBOB)
DeCaprio should have won an Oscar... (Theodoric)
Highlander (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Well said, Phitt (HomeSkillet)
Traffic (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
I hate that "summer escapism" justification for crappy movies. (skilly)
HomeSkillet, skilly: (Morrison_Hotel)
MH (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Whisper (Critico)
geez skilly.... (TheGodmother)
Here's a few: (Morrison_Hotel)
Did somebody say "The Thin Red Line"? (Drew_Atreides)
Well, okay, my favorite movie ever.. (Drew_Atreides)
MH (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
"Tomb Raider", Muses? (Salamander)
Sal (Throwing_Muses)
So sayeth Whispers. (Bickle)
So, skilly, we should give you some sort of badge of honor... (Aron)
Wow, CFL. (skilly)
What's this "Crotching Tiger" business? (Bubbles_Powerpuff)
DiCaprio Musings, Blockbuster Redux, and a Trivia Challenge (BradPhittJr)
Brad: (Morrison_Hotel)
BPJr. (Bickle)
You suck, MH (Bickle)
Bickle: (Morrison_Hotel)
Atreides (Chiz)
If that was his goal... (Bickle)
A fan of "Jackass" worrying about MY hobbies? (Aron)
90% of everything is crap. (Redundancies)
The other stuff (Aron)
Red, as much as I believe in the philosophy "The Writer is Everything"-- (Aron)
There were some movies that I wanted to see... (skilly)
Aron (Nick-The-Knife)
Presley/CFL/Aron/Beavis (Redundancies)
Chiz! (Drew_Atreides)
The last movie I saw in theatres... (Fuck_the_president)
Fair enough (Aron)
Here's a good Keanu movie: "Point Break" (Homeboy)
Gotta love art-snobs (NT) (Lionel_Cosgrove)
Dancer in the Dark... Director/Actors/Writers in the DARK! (Mon_Cul)
In Defense of "Dancer in the Dark" (BradPhittJr)
Ah, Keanu... (BradPhittJr)
WTF??? (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
redundancies (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Well... (Lionel_Cosgrove)
Lionel... (BradPhittJr)
I can understand that... (Lionel_Cosgrove)
"Keanu Reeves = bad actor" (Redundancies)
Brad and Whisper (Aron)
Aron (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
oh yeah... (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
I dunno who this "Keneu" guy is (ShadowEmperor)
Come on, man -- you're reading what you want to read! (Aron)
Aron (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
"Batman Forever" would have been better if V. Kilmer Drank Himself to death (BradPhittJr)
I don't think Nick Deserved the Oscar that year (Critico)
kNIGHT (The_Knight_After)
So, I'm sitting here watching my GET A LIFE DVD (Nick-The-Knife)
You've got the Get A Life DVD? (Bickle)
what? you're sitting in front of the t.v. thinking about (mia_wallace)
Fuck a life. Slater needs TO GET A JOB!!! (MAYORBOB)
I knew it. (skilly)
Bickle, Mia, and skilly (Nick-The-Knife)
I hate you now. (skilly)
Jesus! (Nick-The-Knife)
"but, uh, they were all sold out." (mia_wallace)
what the hell is "get a life", anyway? (mia_wallace)
Oh, Nick... (Lionel_Cosgrove)
listen (mia_wallace)
if i had taken the advice of everyone who said a movie sucked (mia_wallace)
Yes, but... (Lionel_Cosgrove)
araki's point? "a heterosexual movie", of course (snicker). (mia_wallace)
Okay, Mia, you win (Nick-The-Knife)
just take my word for it (mia_wallace)
whoopee! (mia_wallace)
Uh, Mia? (Nick-The-Knife)
For a bit of fun, my partner has just posted a new short film on the net . (Hairhead)
Bob Barr: Defender of the First Amendment. (MAYORBOB)
We will...we will... (Jack-Em-Up_JACKAL)
Here's a Mothers Day story that will make you want to throw up. (MAYORBOB)
I've actually been through gelderland . (lurker)
A Calvin & Hobbes cartoon (Zorro)
Y'know, I learned something here today.... (TheWreck)
Ten Interesting Medieval Facts (aterry33)
Theodoric of York: Medieval Barber! (Bickle)
RE: Beer with Breakfast - OR - MY Rice Krispies go "hic". (TheWreck)
Why doth thou not touch on "droit du seignor"? Knight's piece of tail (MAYORBOB)
Ring Around The Rosey... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
I knew a couple of those (Mr-Mucus)
The "plague" theory of "Ring-around-the-rosie"... (Wulfgar)
This is a good spot to post this. . . (Bubbles_Powerpuff)
I learned that "Ring Around the Rosey" was... (Pseudonym)
Re: Ten Interesting Medieval Facts (ode2barbie)
ode2barbie... (Wulfgar)
Re: Ten Interesting Medieval Facts (ode2barbie)
13th Knight (ode2barbie)
I've heard that one... (Wulfgar)
odetobarbie: (Wulfgar)
not to mention.... (ode2barbie)
Damn, where's Theo.... (miss_enthropic_bitch)
ode2barbie... . (lurker)
Mead. . . (Bubbles_Powerpuff)
Mead... (Wulfgar)
And the "truth" about Ring Around The Rosey... (skilly)
Re: Ten Interesting Medeival Movie Facts (skorzenyII)
Pepsi... (ode2barbie)
Mountain Dew... (Shadow)
Give her a coke. . . (Bubbles_Powerpuff)
The longest post I have ever made. (Theodoric)
Another thing to remember about Richard the Lionhearted... (Bickle)
Re: King arthur (lurker)
That's entirely possible, lurker (Theodoric)
skorzeny... (Wulfgar)
Hey, Wulf, Didja' know... (Theodoric)
No shit! (Wulfgar)
the term "beating the hell out of someone" (mia_wallace)
Achoo, achoo, we all fall down (Karen_G)
What’s this? An opportunity to rip on LADYHAWKE and no one tells me? (Philm_Phan)
Incidentally... (StrollingPlayersCompany)
recommendation (Shakesmear)
Missing medieval movie mentions (Mr-Mucus)
Interesting Arthur (tiny spoilers)... (Wulfgar)
I thought RBB wrote "The Swinging Sword..." (skilly)
Some Medieval-Fantasy films/shows I liked (Theodoric)
Re: Ten Interesting Medieval Facts (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
"They are the Gutter of BritComs." (Wulfgar)
Forgive Whisper, for he knows not what he speaks. (MAYORBOB)
The best medieval movie I've ever seen (Ken_Kaminski)
Some other medieval movies (Zorro)
And ice cold duck. . . (Bubbles_Powerpuff)
Lance'o Lake, period movie music, and more medieval movies (zorikh)
Arthur's Body (zorikh)
Well, gang, thanks for educating me on all this fourteenth century stuff (Coaster)
Coaster. (Bickle)
A plague on your house! (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
zorikh (Philm_Phan)
I was always partial to the origin of... (The_Hate_Guy)
Just to be on the safe side... (The_Hate_Guy)
walking in armor (zorikh)
What would Chaucer call himself, if he lived today? (MAYORBOB)
No. (Bickle)
Chaucie Gardiner, of course (Philm_Phan)
Sir Geoffry of course... (Fuck_the_president)
well... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
Ringo... (Wulfgar)
Twouldst calleth oneself... (skorzenyII)
If Chaucer were alive today? (convenor)
Emichauce ? Chaucimem ? (The_Knight_After)
I hated that movie! (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Really, Philm Phan... (Ken_Kaminski)
I wonder what the problem about Monty Python is for Whisper? (MAYORBOB)
Re: What would Chaucer call himself, if he lived today? (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Penelope Keith? (Wulfgar)
um, no (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
"Penelope Keith is satire". (Wulfgar)
Wulf (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Whisper (Ken_Kaminski)
I know what a "metaphor" is... (Wulfgar)
Never mind Python for now — Douglas Adams died yesterday! (Philm_Phan)
And now to Python et al (Philm_Phan)
p.s. (Philm_Phan)
um, no (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Re: Brit-coms (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
If... (Wulfgar)
Joining PP in her RIP (KTK)
<sigh> (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
If you pompous Brits don't shut your self-satisfied cakeholes... (Bickle)
Pompous Brits? (KTK)
Yes, what’s with the plural? (Philm_Phan)
I include all pseudo-Brits in the above statement. (Bickle)
There's a word for them, Bickle (convenor)
Britta-bees? (Philm_Phan)
No, that would be Brita bees (one T, you see) (convenor)
Call 'em what you want... (Bickle)
Coined it yourself? (Philm_Phan)
p.s. Bickle (Philm_Phan)
Oh, that's right, the Queen's German. We can't have that. (Bickle)
Sheesh, they've lived in the neighborhood for damn near three centuries now (convenor)
Actually, convenor . . (Hairhead)
HH, you beat me to it (Philm_Phan)
Yes, and bring back the Stuarts the.Old.Pretender (Philm_Phan)
Not Stripes . . . (convenor)
It's nice to see there are still a few Jacobites around... (Bickle)
To which a Londoner would answer, Bickle: (Philm_Phan)
convenor (Philm_Phan)
To which the Scotsman would reply: Bonnie Prince (Bickle)
To which the Londoner would think: (Philm_Phan)
The Londoner wouldn't be thinking much of anything... (Bickle)
Tsk, such recourse to violence (Philm_Phan)
Britcoms, etc., getting here late (Karen_G)
An excellent Britcom: (Wulfgar)
Where is the flag of England (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
A joke (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Karen (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
Best Britcom of all time: (Bickle)
hmmmm (KTK)
The League of Gentleman was showing on Comedy Central when I left. (Bickle)
I forgot about the Young Ones, Bickle (Karen_G)
As you could probably guess... Rider at the Gates of Dawn (Bickle)
Piss off! (Wulfgar)
Re: (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
Just don't eat the special stuff (KTK)
Poll time... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
THat's nothing (Whisper_and_Sabrina)
The special stuff (KTK)
KTK... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
Geoff Chaucer? (Redundancies)
There mustn't be much demand these days for lard-arsed Yorkshiremen (Edgar_Britt)
Another one? (Morrison_Hotel)
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "A Knight's Tale " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!