Batman Begins
Mr. Cranky's rating:
Was the cameraman being chased by a bear? That's how chaotic the action scenes are.
Here's something that many film producers don't get: A talent for directing drama doesn't necessarily indicate a talent for directing action. Take "Pearl Harbor" director Michael Bay, for instance. He's built a career out of huge action movies coupled with some of the worst drama known to mankind.
Christopher ("Memento") Nolan cannot direct an action sequence to save his life. In fact, he and his editor appear to have so little idea about how to shoot the action sequences in "Batman Begins" that it's hard to imagine that two of any other type of primate could have produced worse. The action sequences are uniquely incompetent. They are the cinematic equivalent of watching NASCAR driver Jeff Gordon plow into his pit crew for no apparent reason.
Like a dark version of Dr. Phil, Christopher Nolan tries to take us into the heart and mind of Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale) and explore Batman's inner demons. Thus, we're treated to Wayne's search for his soul in a Bhutanese prison and his eventual tutoring at the hands of everybody's favorite mentor, Liam Neeson. Here he plays Henri Ducard, assistant to ninja leader Ra's Al Ghul (Ken Watanabe). Watching Neeson provide life lessons to yet another student has all the charms of watching Richard Simmons beg another fat person to stop eating.
After learning all he needs about being tough and seeking justice, Wayne returns to a deteriorating Gotham, where assistant district attorney Rachel Dawes (Katie Holmes) and detective James Gordon (Gary Oldman) fight the good fight, while Dr. Jonathan Crane (Cillian Murphy) and Carmine Falcone (Tom Wilkinson) work to tear Gotham apart. With the help of Lucius Fox (Morgan Freeman) and the good butler Alfred (Michael Caine), Wayne adopts his alter ego.
Several critical action scenes dot the dramatic palette of Wayne's search for his soul: a fight at Al Ghul's compound, Batman's first ride in the Hummer-meets-Ninja batmobile, and the inevitable final showdown. Not once-in any of these scenes-is the audience allowed to see one damn thing, and I mean NOTHING. Was the cameraman being chased by a bear? That's how chaotic the action scenes are.
I've made this point before, but I'll keep making it as long as I have to: The first rule of any action scene should be that the audience gets to see the action. Why isn't this obvious? Could anyone imagine watching a football game in which the camera was zooming in and out so fast that the action was merely an afterthought? Sure, there's such a thing as style, but Nolan has raised his action "style" to a level of ridiculousness that negates every accomplishment in the film.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Batman Begins" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "Batman Begins" forum
Messages:
Mr. Cranky you ROCK!!! OneBouncingSoul
The King Kong trailer Veruca_Salt
Just spend six days in Vegas; first time there... morganlefey
Pre-Teen DA ChrisH
Sleater-Kinney rocks Ickyru
Lastsies Rajah
I've just got one thing to say... Screwtape
The Internet Is Shit. church
- - - Give Alex Jones A Chance - - - PsychoRabbit
AS YOUR EMISARRY TO THE UN, MY FIRST RULE WILL BE TO KILL THE EAGLES John_Bolton
Winn- Dixie to close stores Rajah
I'M CALLING YOU ALL OUT! John_Bolton
Oscar says, "No" to stunt performers mangy-ranger
Was I the only one confused by the Katie Holmes character? JaneTheeIgnorantSlut
You better hope Wal-Mart doesn't want your house. Marie50
They are going to outlaw flag burning? Rajah
Strip club review!! Marie50
AFI blows it again Eddie_Dean
I'm on a Brando kick Ken_Kaminski
Estelle Getty is looking mighty good to me now Rajah
Question for Monkeyking/Batray - skilly/Slothrop Aron
Ex-gay camp jinxipop
LOVED this movie. the_demon
Funk Punk Aron
Two can play this game, Coaster! Theodoric
Bored? How about an amusing story? Coaster
All these alien invasion movies are preparing us for the real invasion Rajah
Buck is a scary motherfucker Theodoric
Canteen Boy found in Utah Rajah
shuld i type liek tHis? X-Man
T Rex: best bad ever? Ken_Kaminski
Democrat Senator Durbin apologizes for remarks X-Man
War of the Worlds Online.com Rajah
Kiss me, I'm a pirate <nt> X-Man
Corgan to reform Smashing Pumpkins. Throwing_Muses
Now Julie baby, it ain't natural for you to cry in the midnight Ken_Kaminski
Nearly 9,000 Americans may have died in Iraq War PsychoRabbit
Aron, you fatass X-Man
The return of the hilarypics X-Man
Perfect Man did 5.3 million X-Man
Yikes! This chick is scary even by *my* standards Theodoric
All our times have come Rajah
Rajah has a birthday??? archivist
I hear McDonald's will start selling Chicken McTarsals... MonkeyKing
What next? mangy-ranger
Unlike hick news from Georgia/Alabama/Walmart towns, San Francisco brings John_Doe
Sometimes "LOL" just doesn't do something justice Aron
The problem with film critics Ken_Kaminski
It's hellbilly's bday! archivist
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
Christian Bale leads in Sexiest Vegetarian Alive poll karmacopia
Poll: What should have been done over Iraq? Theodoric
Better formatting Theodoric
International diplomacy... PsychoRabbit
E) grundle
This wasn't our war to fight Rajah
Don't start the war in the first place. Throwing_Muses
E Eddie_Dean
Random musings.... daz
Survey says... ModernRonin
Uncharacteristically for me, I have an opinion Coaster
F. DARKER_MR_MUCUS
U. Jerk-in-the-Box
E) Nuclear proliferation is a fact Dan_in_Cincinnati
Coaster, have you considered switching to Sanka? Theodoric
I poured my blood, sweat, and tears into this and that is the reply I get? Coaster
Well, you know, Coaster. Your post... Theodoric
Well, I hate to pop Coaster's bubble in regards to Kerry, The_Third_Nipple
Naturally... The_Hate_Guy
Hate guy Eddie_Dean
Is Hate Guy gay for John Kerry, too? X-Duff
The_Hate_Guy, I think I speak for many of us here when I say Coaster
We never should have invaded Iraq. karmacopia
You complete me. karmacopia
Pray tell? Rajah
Watch your words, Rajah. PsychoRabbit
Yes I can Rajah
They never did... PsychoRabbit
Rajah wasn't referring to that type of dyke Rajah
Nothing wrong with people fighting their own fights, but . . . The_Third_Nipple
True enough, Third_Nipple... M_H
Never have figured out why isolationism is a dirty word. ModernRonin
Genocide is different situation Rajah
Isolationism means you don't help people, either Mr_Nonsense
The same reason we are friends with fucking Saudi Arabia Rajah
Bush starting to take heat from supporters over Iraq Theodoric
Alan yumming exits X-Men 3 Mr_Nonsense
If I was a normal guy, I'd be having sex right now. grundle
My advice Rajah
No, she did not want to have sex with you. gnosticdogma
Stalkerboy starts another obsession James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
See Critico
101 Reasons Not To Have Sex Rajah
Rajah grundle
gnosticdogma grundle
James_Duck_Dodgers_IV grundle
Critico grundle
Jesus Christ. Fierce_Molly
Fierce Molly grundle
It sounds like you're beaten before you've begun Dr_Freud
They can also smell grundle a mile away Jerk-in-the-Box
Dr_Freud grundle
Jerk-in-the-Box grundle
Morals didn't stop you from humping her X-grundle-Man
Women don't really care about looks. gnosticdogma
Grundle's going to have a problem with that. Wrath_Of_Dog
Dunno about having sex...... daz
Well, you could ask her out for coffee... M_H
You recently found out you have Asperger's? Terribelle
Hit 'um lady on head with big 'um rock Gordon_Bigfoot
gnosticdogma grundle
M_H grundle
Terribelle grundle
Grundle Coaster
Coaster grundle
Jesus, Coaster. gnosticdogma
I'm not surprised grundle has ass purger's syndrome Jerk-in-the-Box
I read Mark Haddon's book Ken_Kaminski
After reading The Five People You Meet in Heaven Coaster
If she's a ditz.... daz
Intelligent women fuck much better Ken_Kaminski
Creepy Ann Coulter way sounds good Mr_Nonsense
daz grundle
Hindsight is 20/20 Aron
Be *friends*? She's a woman for God's sake! PsychoRabbit
Aron grundle
Depends on what "low maintenance" means Mr_Nonsense
She called herself that Aron
Thank you for the compliment, Ken Terribelle
I thought grundle had Asshole's Syndrome X-Duff
Gov. Moon Beam got married last Saturday mangy-ranger
I see this one "jeans and a t-shirt" girl around town all the time Ken_Kaminski
Thread summary: MonkeyKing
One advice, Monkey: PsychoRabbit
Terrible 'um Pinkskin Woman, Gordon no injun! Gordon_Bigfoot
gdog and grundle beg the question: Terribelle
Chances of grundull getting laid James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Ranger Rick? Terribelle
Dingbats Rajah
I understand, Rajah Terribelle
I don't actually have herpes. gnosticdogma
What about space herpes? Mr_Nonsense
I didn't see her today. grundle
Dig 'um big pit in front of her 'um apartment Gordon_Bigfoot
She could see grundle again in 6 minutes X-Duff
Talk about a nobody Terribelle
Aron Critico
I wasn't "introduced" for the purpose of matchmaking Aron
Not to split hares, but the Easter Bunny gets some hot chick Mr_Nonsense
ok Critico
I'm glad to see X-Man
Whoa! X-Man
What did she look like? X-Man
I totally see the situation though X-Man
Terribelle X-Man
X-MAN grundle
grundle Critico
Critico grundle
Other symptoms of Asperger's X-grundle-Man
That's not what you said before, X Terribelle
And you remember this why? X-Man
24 I would rather go to the theater than to a museum. gnosticdogma
Wonder if gundle has disposed of the body yet? Liquid_Technomage
wikipedia article for X-MAN grundle
All this time, I thought your non-driving was a matter of choice Coaster
Coaster grundle
That test sucked Ken_Kaminski
Why I remember Terribelle
Cuz u love me X-Man
Yes, I do Terribelle
i.e. gnosticdogma
Rajah is an excellent driver Rajah
grundle Critico
Critico grundle
I did not play pretend or make believe... Slothrop
That's not true in my case, g Terribelle
Early titles for Douglas Woods' tale of Iraqi kidnapping. Throwing_Muses
Natalie Portman with a shaved head in 'V for Vendetta'. Throwing_Muses
Mr & Mrs Smith - fun but mindless. ModernRonin
SUV owners spend $58/gallon for mud to put on their SUVs. grundle
The funny thing about regret is Theodoric
***Rajah*** the breakfast cereal that bites back Rajah
The Laffer Curve is real, because people respond to incentives. grundle
"Batman Begins" on course to make same first 5 day gross as "Batman Forever Aron
Hooray for liberal Democrats John Kerry and Barney Frank! grundle
I've got a political question Rajah
So what was the best train action sequence of all time? GreatCthulhu
AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
If you won more than 150 porn videos, you must register with the FEDS!! 0b1knob
Watched the E Hollywood story of "Bewitched" Rajah
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
Uh oh. 47.2% (+/- 3%) of the population has an annual income that is below grundle
Now I'm engaged Corduroy_Thong
Those Batman Animated Series fanboys are seriously pissing me off Drew_Atreides
Necrosis of the scrotum... Twitching_Shyt_Bag
I've got a question Rajah
Is Katie Holmes a virgin? Spanky
My girlfriend's Kunny Twitching_Shyt_Bag
Something has happened to my brother Rajah
Hey Cranky - how about a review of "Serenity"? ModernRonin
The Complete Calvin And Hobbes - Oct 4 - Hardcover - 3 Vols - 1,440 pages grundle
Primer - incredibly intreging, yet baffling, film... (poss spoilers) M_H
The first Batman was the best, are bruces parent's killed in this one? TMundo
Alex Jones: PsychoRabbit
Supersize Me Omega_Man
As I was saying about the original "War of the Worlds..." PsychoRabbit
Faux News reports on some of the contents of the Downing Street Memo Dan_in_Cincinnati
Batman Begins matt755811
A majority of Americans now disapprove of Bush Mr_Happy_Face
Could we have an amendment to the lynching law for this fucker? Theodoric
The action sequences really are horribly shot.. Drew_Atreides
Here's hoping the world ends before next friday Rajah
And the seasons, they round and round Rajah
WTF Rajah
For posterity Ken_Kaminski
Levers church
Batman, Begin Again Theodoric
Hilary 68 on Forbes celebrity Pay list X-Man
Dearest Wife, this is what I want for Fathers Day... Darth-Shithead
Blockbuster is pretty lame now X-Man
Umm, since Memento was way overrated X-Man
Oh this mofo Cnarky SUCKS X-Man
Coaster Begins (this forum with a firsties) Coaster
Socko! Theodoric
BAM! Rajah
Zok! Theodoric
Kazowie! Rajah
Meanwhile, back at the... Theodoric
Batman is rubbing... Rajah
Actually, if Burt Ward's book is truthful Theodoric
Scene: Coaster's home, Thursday nights . . . Hairhead
Bottomsies Begins Oh_Dear_God_Make_It_Stop
BLAM! KAPOWIE!!!! Rajah
What's THIS? Theodoric
The BOTTOMSIES tale of firsties Eddie_Dean
Yes, that's how Verooka Skank used to get them, too Theodoric
There's no honor amongst bottomsies thieves Rajah
Well, then. I guess all's fair in love and... Theodoric
Love means never having to say you're sorry Rajah
Ali MacGraw Eddie_Dean
Yeah but she had a great pair of..... Rajah
Rajah blew BOTTOMSIES Eddie_Dean
Good Job, HH, re: Coaster... mendo
Err... Theodoric
Rules rules rules! Rajah
Enough talk, it's time for action! Theodoric
We need rules Eddie_Dean
What if the only rule is: "There are no rules"? Coaster
as timmy would often say Eddie_Dean
Lassie should have given up on ole Timmy Rajah
Who woulda thunk... Eddie_Dean
I, too, am a man of letters Theodoric
I just got off the phone with Disney Eddie_Dean
If Walt were still here Rajah
Rajah is obviously a deviant Theodoric
Actually, as a kid one time at Disneyland Eddie_Dean
Disneyland = Neverland Rajah
All right, that's enough of this un-nostalgic talk! Theodoric
When you wish upon a star! Rajah
Oh My God! They killed Jiminy! Theodoric
Enough of this Chinese myth Eddie_Dean
The bouncers always throw me out on my bottomsies Rajah
Always figured you for a Chippendale's kinda guy Eddie_Dean
I only go to "Gentleman's Clubs" Theodoric
Chipmonk bottomsies are too small to pat Rajah
I like big BOTTOMSIES and I cannot lie! Theodoric
Frankly, my dears, I don't give a damn Eddie_Dean
I don't know nothing 'bout Rajah
Somewhere, over the rainbow Theodoric
And as God is my witness, I'll never be hungry again! Rajah
I coulda been a contender Theodoric
Here's looking at you kid Rajah
Soylent Brown... Eddie_Dean
GET YOUR STINKING HANDS OFF MY BOTTOMSIES Rajah
Twas, Rajah Eddie_Dean
Kid, you're good Theodoric
What's BOTTOMSIES? Eddie_Dean
I can't believe you silly muthas are still at this Coaster
Bottomsies? Rajah
This is just the beginning of the... Eddie_Dean
This is the end Theodoric
Come on, baby Eddie_Dean
Smoke on the water Theodoric
"BOTTOMSIES!," he uttered. Eddie_Dean
Ray Harryhausen pioneered the art of... Theodoric
before he died, I met ray harryhausen at his home Eddie_Dean
No shit? Theodoric
He was a very friendly person and loved talking about his collection Eddie_Dean
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "Batman Begins " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!