12/20/02: The most overrated director?

Posted By: Bob_St_Cul

C'mon--there have to be more deserving candidates out there...

Responses to this message:

• I'd go with the_demon
• I don't think you can call DePalma overrated.. Drew_Atreides
• Re: The most overrated director? Maniac-Cop
• John Woo last_angry_man
• Spike Lee MR_MUCUS
• Overrated. . . Marion
• Re: The most overrated director? TickedOffOldSchooler
• I agree on Fincher... Maniac-Cop
• Re: The most overrated director? barsoom
• Thpthpthpthpppp! I like woo and I like Spielberg. Here's my five nominees Coaster
• Maybe I'll change my vote. last_angry_man
• I gotta go with Altman, too. Theodoric
• And, in my opinion, some other overrated directors Theodoric
• I would agree with Altman... Aron
• The Player was a pretty good flick... M_H
• Yeah, i find John Woo overrated, too Drew_Atreides
• Tarantino...I forgot about him, MR_MUCUS
• Damn you Soderberg! CaptainVideo
• What a carnival of ignorance this thread is! Bickle
• I love Bickle! Aron
• Tarantino influenced a quarter of the films in the past eight years? Theodoric
• Ridley Scott isn't overated Theodoric
• Yeah, Scott has shown that he HAS the stuff for good movies Drew_Atreides
• Tarantino movies doesn't have shitty music. Stuck in the middle Critico
• Spielberg is on an upswing X-MAN
• Re: The most overrated director? X-MAN
• I'm surprised no one has mentioned... miss_enthropic_bitch
• I really dug Full Frontal... Bickle
• He has to have SOME influence on that aspect of the film, Bick.. Drew_Atreides
• Most overrated directors: Slater
• David Lynch Aron
• Gladiator was servicable... Bickle
• "Aliens is a haunted house movie in space" Theodoric
• David Cronenberg kicks ass... M_H
• James Cameron StarOfEight
• Fuck Tarantino StarOfEight
• Not a Woody Allen fan. Wargasm
• was Wargasm
• StarofEight and Wargasm really nailed it. Theodoric
• No. Bickle
• "Not a bad director, just shallow" Theodoric
• Re: The most overrated director? Ken_Kaminski
• Demon, re: Brian De Palma: PsychoRabbit
• QUIT REFRENCING DIRECTORS KNOWN FOR THEIR SPECIAL EFFECTS! Bickle
• one last post in this thread Theodoric
• If Malcolm MacDowell was touted as a GREAT actor... Bickle
• Fair enough. Theodoric
• Hmm.. Drew_Atreides
• Alien was influential Coaster
• I would see ALIEN 5 MR_MUCUS
• Influential is not necessarily a good thing MR_MUCUS
• Since I started this... Bob_St_Cul
• Paul Verhoven? Bob_St_Cul
• Never assume MR_MUCUS
• Starship Troopers is a fucking brilliant satire. Bickle
• Satire is lost on most people MR_MUCUS
• "repackage" (nt) MR_MUCUS
• Hey Mucus miss_enthropic_bitch
• Starship Trooper *is* pretty good satire Theodoric
• And Heinlien was jewish, wasn't he? MR_MUCUS
• Maybe he was a self-hater Bickle
• The story i heard about "Starship Troopers" Drew_Atreides
• No way was Verhoven not responsible for the cheese factor. Bickle
• What about the dark comedy that was "Show Girls"? MR_MUCUS
• It might be a Neumeier staple, Bickle Drew_Atreides
• Not Wes Anderson gionk
• Re: The most overrated director? Ebineezer

Post a response to this discussion thread