Don't Say a word

Bomb Rating: 

What, exactly, is the problem with grabbing Elisabeth and thumping on her until she talks?

We know Dr. Nathan Conrad is a great psychiatrist because at the beginning of the movie, he tells a male teenage patient that masturbation is perfectly normal and that everyone does it and we, the audience, think to ourselves, "Wow, what a sympathetic guy." He even explains to the kid how to clean his keyboard off after one too many visits to www.he8teenbeaver.com.

Conrad's wife, Aggie (Famke Janssen) is laid up in bed with a broken leg and their daughter, Jesse (Skye McCole Bartusiak), likes to play hide-and-seek games when Daddy gets home. Daddy comes home and Jesse is hiding in a closet. This provides director Gary ("Things to Do in Denver When You're Dead") Fleder the perfect opportunity to run the camera around their New York apartment in a particularly menacing way right after the girl is kidnapped by Patrick Koster (Sean Bean). This situation also allows Koster to terrorize Aggie while Nathan is away at the psychiatric hospital trying to convince a new patient, Elisabeth Burrows (Brittany Murphy), to cough up some number that will allow Koster to find a particularly valuable jewel.

The history of this gem is extraordinarily convoluted. Elisabeth is the daughter of one of Koster's former partners, and she watched Pop get offed when he wouldn't talk. To thwart her capture, she's pretended to be insane and moved from hospital to hospital her whole childhood. Dr. Conrad figures this out in about five seconds, because he's under phenomenal pressure lest his daughter be killed, and such observations just come naturally to people in situations like that.

Koster and his criminal buddies have staked out Conrad's apartment and the hospital so perfectly that you wonder why they can't just get the damn number out of her themselves. They don't seem to have too many qualms about threatening Dr. Conrad's family, so what, exactly, is the problem with grabbing Elisabeth and thumping on her until she talks? No matter where Nathan goes, it seems there's a camera or a microphone. The apartment is totally decked out with them, and there's even a listening device in the vent in Elisabeth's psychiatric hospital room. Hey, guys, while you were in the room installing the microphone, how about grabbing the girl harboring your big, important secret? SHE WAS STANDING RIGHT THERE. Nobody noticed you crawling around in the ductwork, I doubt they're going to see you grab some mental patient. Lord knows they didn't notice when somebody snatched the competent scriptwriter.

To spread the word about this Don't Say a word review on Twitter.

To get instant updates of Mr. Cranky reviews, subscribe to our RSS feed.
0 Comments

Like This Don't Say a word Review? Vote it Up.

0

Rate This Movie:

Other Cranky Content You Might Enjoy

  • I guess I was expecting something more from Danny Boyle, given that so much was made of the fact that the director of "Trainspotting" was going to tackle the horror genre.

    Sadly, this film does not

  • Force Itzak Perlman to consume the amount of caffeine and amphetaminesit would take to make an elephant launch patties out its ass like scud missiles and you still couldn't get him to produce more vio

  • I already suffered through this film once, when it was called "Secret Window." "Hide and Seek" has the exact same "twist" ending, which is much less a twist than it is a joke.