The Golden Compass
Mr. Cranky's rating:
I feel like I'm stuck at a traffic light that's not going to change from red for awhile.
If the conservative jackasses who are railing against this movie for being anti-Christian would spend a couple of hours and actually see the thing, they could immediately legitimize themselves and rail against it for a good reason: it sucks.
It's not so much that "The Golden Compass" is incomprehensible, it's just really not all that interesting or compelling and it's painful that it's apparently going to be the first movie in a trilogy. I feel like I'm stuck at a traffic light that's not going to change from red for awhile.
While librarians and bookstore owners are undoubtedly thrilled about the interest in reading produced by "Harry Potter" and all the subsequent books that rode its coattails to bestseller status, the resulting ideas are exponentially less interesting, kind of like that sci-fi theory that repeated cloning eventually results in DNA corruption. There's just a hollowness to it all. Let's see, there was Tolkien and C.S. Lewis and Rowling and how about some new fucking ideas, huh? Fantasy is so yesterday and I'm just sick as shit of wizards and talking animals and guys on horses swatting stuff with swords. You've read one, you've read them all. "The Golden Compass" is just a different acid-takers version of "The Chronicles of Narnia." "Eragon" was the worst of it, but "The Golden Compass" isn't much better.
The world of "The Golden Compass" is an alternate universe where things and names for things are basically the same. One big difference in existence is that every human lives side-by-side with their spirit or daemon, an idea that largely seems born out of the ability of CGI to depict such things. The main character is Lyra Belacqua (Dakota Blue Richards) who discovers that kids are disappearing and is given a magical device by her uncle, Lord Asriel (Daniel Craig) that allows her to know what's true and what isn't. It's a golden compass, sort of. In our world, it's called the Bible, bitch. She travels about, meets polar bears who wear armor, and eventually solves the mystery of the missing children.
Of course, this does little to explain the detail of the world of "The Golden Compass", but I have to say, I didn't really care. Everyone had a little animal that followed them around, bears talk - what more do I need to know? Being that this is a British creation, Sam Elliott as aeronaut Lee Scoresby does seem ridiculously out-of-place. It's kind of like having an opera interrupted by a guy pissing on the floor. Maybe Scoresby is an "aw, shucks" westerner in the book, but it still seems laughably miscast and I kept expecting Sam to break out a case of Coors and get Lyra drunk.
Ah, if only I had been drunk watching this overblown piece of fantasy dreck.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "The Golden Compass" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "The Golden Compass" forum
Messages:
Xur is retard and a weenie like a little girl! X-Man
MSNBC Breaking News: Consumer spending surges by 1.1%, most in 3.5 years X-Man
Jamie Lynn Spears is pretty hot X-Man
Just imagine the media coverage if these kids had been Iraqi prisoners! X-Man
Babies are booming in the USA, unlike other dying liberal western nations X-Man
Jamie Lynn Spears like most femal, lied a lot in interview before pregnancy X-Man
Nobody believes NIE report that Iran has stopped nuke program X-Man
Government airport screeners become hated X-Man
Global warming causes record snow in New England X-Man
At least she has a nice laugh Rajah
Bush leads US economy into recession. Throwing_Muses
Asteroid my hit Mars Rajah
hillary and edmund muskie jwilson07
Yah00 explains 10 tips for approaching women. grundle, read on... Throwing_Muses
Does anyone have an opinion of "Serenity"? scarlet_ohara
Headline: Cheney sets White House office alight during crack pipe mishap Oddball
Bush trashed the climate talks. But look what Gore did. Ickyru
Ron Paul keeps campaign contribution from white supremacist Oddball
Censorship is un-American Nuke_Mecca
Xur
And the White Trash Saga continues... LittleBigGirl
The free market rulz! convenor
Woman testifies before Congress that she was raped Rajah
Batman/The office mashup, "Dwight Knight" X-Man
Feds block California emissions rules X-Man
Thank you, George W. Bush, for keeping us safe convenor
Why Deep-Diving Mammals Don't Black Out Rajah
Klancredo calls it quits Ickyru
The Vatican on The Golden Compass Rajah
God has smiled upon you this day... Drew_Atreides
My Christmas Gift to Crankyland includes.... TMundo
Long long long campaign ahead. jwilson07
Oddball, I think you only PRETEND to care about global warming. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Walmart Thingy The_Shill
The I Used to Love that Cartoon Until its Untimely Cancelation Thread TMundo
Coming soon.. the_demon
I might have been wrong about Ron Paul X-Man
Employers Grab Accident Victim's Cash. LittleBigGirl
Norway's carbon emissions rise 80% X-Man
Here's an idea for all you teachers Rajah
Huckabee lead Democrats in key state of Ohio X-Man
Liberal sex education works again, 16 year old Jamie Lynn Spears pregnant X-Man
Help wanted! RidingFool
At some point i'm sure they'll try and remake The Last Unicorn... TMundo
Why dont people talk about the fact Osama Bin Laden is obviously dead? X-Man
I find the weirdest shit on youtube X-Man
"Hobbit" movie on the way! Mad-Ness_Monster
CBC's review of Kiterunner (spoilers) Mal_Content
Saudi king pardons rape victim sentenced to 200 lashes Mal_Content
Okay I admit it X-Man
Teacher's global warming warning is YouTube hit Oddball
Huckabee took thousands in gifts, records show X-Man
Has plastic surgery ever made anybody look better? X-Man
Wow, Golden Compass bombed even worse. 9m second week. X-Man
Oh great. More J.R.R.R.R.R. Tolkien crap. Coaster
As governor, Huckabee covered up his son's criminal dog torturing Oddball
Wow, Golden Compass bombed even worse. 9m second week. X-Man
Mike Huckabee is next president of the United States X-Man
McCain - Lieberman in 2008!!!!!! Spanky
Princeton fuckhead pulls a Parlock convenor
Curse of the Golden Flower.: Why CGI is for talentless cheapskates. Prime Mover
When Batman & Robin were clibing up the side of the building & they'd stop. TMundo
Today we learned not to knock the plug out of the digital printer while... TMundo
mild Xmas amusement Shakesmear
The Dark Knight Trailer. Drew_Atreides
Idea for a bumper sticker: Coaster
What's the coolest Christmas gift you've bought for someone this year? Mal_Content
Thoughts on recently-seen movies (SPOILERS) HomeSkillet
So when will the LOTR-inspired movie trend ever begin? The_Third_Nipple
I am Legend vs. Omega Man: Have any of you seen both? Coaster
Sure the Fox News Babes are hot, but can they take a punch? Wallee_Pipps
Here y'all go: RidingFool
Hillary shows up on Fox News Network Spanky
Announcement! jen
Hello DARKNESS Rajah
The Da Vinci rule Tokeloshe
So the cowgirls lost. Throwing_Muses
Ron Paul just raised $6 million in one day. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Dan Fogelberg dead firsties Rajah
Kermit the Frog endorses McCain Rajah
The Arctic is screaming. Mal_Content
The Snowmen are drooling Rajah
Global warming is caused by irrational opposition to nuclear power. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Mal Content Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Whenever I hear anyone cite the Chernobyl disaster as a reason to Captain_Lance_Murdoch
People who cite nuclear waste as a reason to oppose Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Nukes don't deal with the crux of the issue... michael3b
Lance, you are so full of shit over nuke power Ickyru
michael3b Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Michael, transportation is 27% of all GHG emissions in the US Ickyru
I've already taken action. MR_MUCUS
Ickyru, I cited sources to back up my claims. You did not. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Ickyru, one more thing.... Captain_Lance_Murdoch
France's socialist nuc pow proves that Libertarians and enviros are wrong. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Opponents of nuclear power don't have a realisitc solution to global warmin Captain_Lance_Murdoch
France is my real world role model for clean energy. What's yours??????? Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Perhaps we might do several things? jwilson07
Lies and the lying liars who tell them Ickyru
The problem of baseline energy supply is not insuperable with renewables Ickyru
jwilson07 Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Ickyru Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Ickyru... Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Ickyru, those are 2 seperate posts for you. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
What a switch! I favor something socialist, and Ickyru opposes it! Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Hahah - well, I'd still Ickyru
People who cite nuclear power as a solution to global warming Throwing_Muses
<abandons the nuclear powered car idea> Rajah
Soylent Fuel is the way to go. Mr_Nonsense
Throwing Muses Captain_Lance_Murdoch
An alternative real-world model of clean energy Ken_Kaminski
Betty Rubble Rajah
Lance... Mal_Content
Mal Content Captain_Lance_Murdoch
You're wrong on that, Lance. So very wrong. Here's why.... Coaster
By the way, nice transition... Coaster
Re: The Arctic is screaming.-because of Canadian oil X-Man
What Coaster said. Mal_Content
The Arctic is screaming--because of Oddball
Grundle Ken_Kaminski
Ken Kaminski Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Coaster Captain_Lance_Murdoch
You're grasping, Lance. Mal_Content
There are no anarchist societies Ken_Kaminski
Speaking of The Dark Knight, who's your favourite superhero? Mal_Content
The Golden Compass: Better than Dexter Coaster
Bootleg IMAX preview of THE DARK KNIGHT (Batman) MR_MUCUS
I just saw the Darjeeling Express. RidingFool
Brief no-spoiler review of I AM LEGEND. MR_MUCUS
The only movie I've liked of Will Smith's was Men in Black Rajah
Strange comparisons other post apocalyptic films (minor spoilers) MR_MUCUS
what Charlton Heston brought to Omega Man, he also brought to Soylent Green Coaster
Whats wrong with Ben Hur? jwilson07
I can splain those lions.... jwilson07
Wilson, I hate being preached to Coaster
How does this film compare to A boy and his Dog? Rajah
Hate being preached to, then you'll be disappointed by I AM LEGEND MR_MUCUS
It's not a matter of hating America. RidingFool
Saying that someone "hates America" is a way to limit discussion... M_H
M_H, only an extremist like you would say that Coaster
3rd time socialized medicine story. jwilson07
I go to a Tag Office in Stroud. No waiting. Ever. Coaster
Another tale of THE BEST HEALTH CARE SYSTEM IN THE WORLD Coaster
It doesn't matter if our health care system is abomidably slow lost_cause
What the hell does "socialized" medicine have to do with retirement homes? RidingFool
^^^ What I meant to say was... RidingFool
Riding Fool, I made a joke about your mother once, Mal_Content
Don't sweat it. I make up lots of things. In fact, RidingFool
His mother gave more attention to... Rajah
I have trouble remembering RidingFool
Wouldn't the smell give her away? Rajah
To riding fool, and no insults here. jwilson07
coaster response, no insults here. jwilson07
reply to lost cause, well named . jwilson07
My REVIEW of I AM LEGEND jen
I AM LEGEND=ZzzzZZZzzzZZZZzzzZZZZz Omega_Man
Good Review. Coaster
So, Omega, I AM LEGEND is the discarded refuse of the present? MR_MUCUS
Why vote for Ron Paul for President? Critico
How Hollywood Saved God (On the Golden Compass) Ickyru
How Hollywood Save God (On the Golden Compass) Ickyru
Halliburton covers up gang rape of employee Rajah
Big surprise-War loving Democrats surrender to Bush on war funding again X-Man
Pullman originally drew on Milton's 'Paradise Lost' for inspiration. Prime Mover
Global Warming causes winter blasts to rock northeast, midwest X-Man
Mr. Cranky ignored Nicole's performance Spanky
A lot of what fundamentalists say is right Ken_Kaminski
''neo-fascist propagandists on Fox News..." Bobo
Next President Huckabee now winning Florida, accepting gifts X-Man
jwilson07 The_Third_Nipple
Wow! Huckabee sure did accept a lot of gifts while in office! Coaster
Huckabee took thousands in gifts, records show X-Man
Bush bitching today about the "do nothing" Congress convenor
The Dems are looking interesting again. the_demon
Weekly Poll? Mad-Ness_Monster
Bad adaptation - good movie? Mad-Ness_Monster
Best Political "Ad" of the season Ickyru
Great books that have been made into great movies: Mal_Content
Philip Pullman tries to kill God with fable, God curses his writing skills Scumby
Mal Xur
Bush Approval Rating Returns To All-Time Low Oddball
Experts: Arctic Melt Accelerating Oddball
Muslim Saves Jew from Subway Assault Oddball
Huckabee took thousands in gifts, records show Ickyru
Pushing Daisies is the best show on TV right now Xur
tanstaafl tanstaafl
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "The Golden Compass " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!