|
 |
King Arthur
Mr. Cranky's rating:
This version of "King Arthur" is supposedly based on some kind of new research. After watching the movie, I'm convinced that this so-called research was conducted by a group of barnyard animals on a bender.
Whenever Hollywood filmmakers tackle a subject even remotely historical, they're quick to pawn their version off as the "accurate" version or the "more accurate" version or the "version you haven't heard" or whatever. In truth, "accuracy" means about as much to Hollywood filmmakers as "sobriety" does to Glen Campbell. This version of "King Arthur" is supposedly based on some kind of new research. After watching the movie, I'm convinced that this so-called research was conducted by a group of barnyard animals on a bender. The fact is, historians aren't quite sure about the real King Arthur, so when Hollywood types set their sights on the subject, there's little to stop them from laying waste to everything in their path, not unlike the Saxons in this movie. The elements that made the legend of King Arthur interesting in other films -- such as the story of Arthur's sword and explorations of other characters such as Merlin the magician -- have been removed from this film and replaced by endless conversations between Arthur (Clive Owen) and his knights about gaining their freedom and getting off the dank, boring island that is Britain. Unfortunately, a Roman magistrate shows up and gives them one more mission: Rescue a family up north from the encroaching Saxon hordes. Merlin is portrayed as some kind of tree-hugging face painter living in the forest with his group of dirty woods people. When Arthur goes to rescue the Roman family, he meets Guinevere (Keira Knightley), another dirty woods person (they're kind of like unwashed elves) and damn good with a bow to boot. After more interminable conversations, Arthur and his knights try to figure out a good way to deal with the Saxons, who are led by Cerdic (Stellan Skarsgard). Fortunately for Arthur, the Saxons beat on a drum wherever they go, which I can say with great historical accuracy has proven to be a poor strategy for planning military attacks. Director Antoine ("Training Day") Fuqua is entirely out of his element. For whatever reason, the film begins with a short prologue focused on Lancelot, a sequence that turns out to be utterly pointless as the film then shifts to Arthur and stays there. Like most of his contemporaries, Fuqua can't film an effective action sequence, and though he conceives of an interesting confrontation between Arthur and the Saxons on some unstable ice, he eventually succumbs to typical L.A. stupidity when it comes to any environment where it actually gets cold once in a while. Frankly, given this film's flimsy attitude toward history and producer Jerry Bruckheimer's name on the credits, I was waiting for the scene where a couple of horses run over a cliff and explode on the way down. Sadly, no such luck.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "King Arthur" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "King Arthur" forum
Messages:
- Did it go to video before it made it to theaters? I don't remember the ads TMundo
- i actually wanted to insult the film pink_panther
- Happy birthday, Linda Ronstadt and Forest Whitaker! Eamon
- Is Til Schweiger the kiss of death for a film? Drew_Atreides
- ¿Donde estan los forumos nuevos? Xur
- I love the way they'r promoting this M. Night documentary Scorsese_fan
- Project Greenlight 3 winner announced Scorsese_fan
- FUCK MR. C AND HIS GAY FAMILY FOR ALI G AND BUTTERFLY EFFECT ADS John_Doe
- In the vein of "Santorum", new vulgar word -- Cheney! Hairhead
- "Dodgeball" passed $100M yesterday Aron
- Half-Formed Thoughts on Chopper Coaster
- So, Kobe picks the Lakers Scorsese_fan
- Hot damn! This Mozilla Firefox browser is pretty cool. MonkeyKing
- The Minister of Fear daz
- Who's the best director aged roughly around 30-50 Scorsese_fan
- King Arthur..... daz
- July 30th the best movie weekend ever? Scorsese_fan
- What do you liberals/Democrats think of this DNC proposal? grundle
- Maybe Mary Jane does die in "Spider-Man 2" Scorsese_fan
- Reviews for "I, Robot" so far Scorsese_fan
- You know you're old when...... decrepit Rajah
- Janklow not liable for civil suit damages..but you are! Theodoric
- "CREM"s daz
- Michael Moore new Slimfast spokesman Spanky
- 40 years of living then death. Throwing_Muses
- Anyone here see TWO BROTHERS? Spanky
- *** NEWS FLASH *** KERRY/EDWARDS RECOVERING FROM SPINE REMOVAL SURGERY *** fatburger
- I called this last year. College football polls return control to people. X-Man
- World exclusive Doom III review X-Man
- Tv Horror Movie Hosts lame Rajah
- Nader miffed; wants apology for 'obscene racist epithet' Theodoric
- Blair admits no WMDs in Iraq. Throwing_Muses
- Geoffrey Rush in 'The Life and Death of Peter Sellers' Throwing_Muses
- Talk of a sequel to "Basic Instinct" got me thinking... Scorsese_fan
- Bush takes it up the butt on gay marriage amendment Mr_Happy_Face
- Numerical movies thread... (nt) M_H
- Bush cuts and runs on Kenny Boy Mr_Happy_Face
- Thank heaven for dirty dirty girls... skilly
- Are the Repubbies Crazy? Mike Ditka vs. Barak Obama Coaster
- Hey, remember the 90s? Aron
- "Bourne Supremacy" or "Catwoman"? Aron
- Awesome!!!! Star Trek: ConQuest beta available for download. Awesome!!!! John_ xur
- What do George W. Bush and Ken Lay have in common? convenor
- Rick Santorum is a moron Aron
- A picture for all my fans! Xur
- ::: POLL ::: Kingly Poll The_Innocent_Bystander
- Mike Moore is a traitor, all right... The_Innocent_Bystander
- Hey! Eamon returned in time for his b-day Thursday! archivist
- Happy Bastille Day! Throwing_Muses
- Sharon Stone to do "Basic Instinct 2"... M_H
- Coaster has a new email address! The_Innocent_Bystander
- New GM commercials use Dandy Warhols soundtrack Theodoric
- Democrat convention schedule released. Dan in Cincinnati plans his day. X-Man
- Rajah. X-Man
- Live studio audience of "Jeopardy" Aron
- Neon Genesis Evangelion - weird, fascinating anime... (poss. spoilers) M_H
- going to see this on sunday mia_wallace
- Finally watched "Running Time" (spoilers) Drew_Atreides
- This is why they should outlaw feral/exotic pets Theodoric
- Behold the Unemployed.... miss_enthropic_bitch
- British Man Jailed for Shooting Off His Testicles EEEEEAAAGGHHH!!! sez Theodoric
- Doe=X-Man=xur=SoC Theodoric
- The year of the sequel Scorsese_fan
- Slothy, todays video game topic X-Man
- Pete Townsend's opinion of Michael Moore. 0b1knob
- Maybe the pod people didn't get Proyas Scorsese_fan
- This weekend's box office #s Scorsese_fan
- The RIAA and your fingerprints. Wulfgar
- Got this Spam today Critico
- Big headed actresses Rajah
- Throwing Muses is another poster that annoys X-Man
- And it leaves her lemony fresh! Theodoric
- Are movies today too mean? Aron
- comments X-Man
- Also X-Man
- But if you accept the argument that art reflects life... Throwing_Muses
- It's part of the same push to liberalism X-Man
- You need a blow-job. panther
- Downer movies Rajah
- Rajah gets post of the week In heaven, everything is fine Theodoric
- Huh? Rajah
- Xie's right, Aron. Eamon
- I'm thinking of changing the name X-Man
- No, no, keep it. Eamon
- You have been standing in...... Rajah
- End of thread X-Man
- The beginning of the end Rajah
- Hmm... Becky_Sharp
- The test proved rajah=xg.m X-Man
- Becky's right Aron
- Aron crystallynthegreat
- Interesting Scorsese_fan
- Re: Are movies today too mean? Mikoyan29
- But it doesn't seem to be what they want Scorsese_fan
- Re: Are movies today too mean? Ickyru
- Bear in mind X-Man
- I'm not sure "Notebook" belongs in that category Aron
- "Spidy 2"s ending (spoilers) Scorsese_fan
- Some movies aren't mean... Rajah
- SF Ken_Kaminski
- Thanks, Ken Scorsese_fan
- Well there's a few ridiculous MJ plot twists that I think they'll avoid Ken_Kaminski
- Have to agree with X on this one... skilly
- And Rajah... skilly
- As proven here? MR_MUCUS
- Re: Are movies today too mean? Dude_Ranch
- You aren't agreeing with me skilly X-Man
- "I...dont want to go back to an unrealistic era of all Jimmy Stewart." skilly
- No. X-Man
- No... skilly
- There are still some "upbeat" movies around. morganlefey
- Somebody Needs a Good Dose of The Parent Trap Coaster
- "Dark" movies Scorsese_fan
- I still say they painted themselves into a corner (spoilers) Aron
- Well, aron Scorsese_fan
- Also, I agree with skilly and maybe X-Man Aron
- Morgan Critico
- " River's Edge" Rajah
- Hey hey hey wait one dog gone minute!!! mad Rajah
- Stewart ought to have been shot for making Its a Wonderful Life Coaster
- Huh? Rajah
- You talkin' to me? Coaster
- Strategic Air Command mangy-ranger
- I don't know, Mangy Coaster
- Stewart in the Air Force is a stretch, but I bought it mangy-ranger
- Huh? What you be talking about? Rajah
- mangy Xur
- Jimmy Stewart and the Air Force Coaster
- Xur, I know.... mangy-ranger
- Shirley Temple was a midgit Rajah
- I am gay BTW. xur
- Okay. HomeSkillet
- Controversial music video by rapper. "Why did Bush knock down the towers" John_Doe
- Peeing in public Rajah
- Does anyone notice that Doeboy has an incredible hatred of women? John_Doe
- LIFE OF EAMON J DOYLE. READ AND WEEP. John_Doe
- If Bowling for Columbine is supposedly superior to F9/11... The_Hate_Guy
- mmmm, HMOs...... daz
- Nick Carter's ex-girlfriend: from lesbian to middle-school sex scandal Aron
- "Baadassssss": scariest damn movie I've ever seen Aron
- Isabel Sanford (aka "Weezie" Jefferson) dead at 86... M_H
- More ClearChannel fun! daz
- BushCo can inspire anyone! daz
- How annoying are these new pre-movie commercials? Uber
- Well whaddya know? Bush's military records "accidentally" destroyed Mr_Happy_Face
- Mouseion #1 is out... Beast
- Why I think the Shaq trade is good for Miami Uber
- Bush Administration considers plan to postpone elections Uber
- Like those A&W restaurants X-Man
- Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
- Spiderman trumps King Arthur at the Box Office MR_MUCUS
- Check this out Xur X-Man
- Someone left the cake out in the rain Rajah
- About that F9/11 <spoilers maybe> Dude_Ranch
- Don't you hate it when... Xur
- Thoughts on recently-seen movies. HomeSkillet
- Lyn Cheney quote on TV "news"... daz
- Prelude to empire Xur
- Fahrenheit 9/11 Tops $80,000,000 Coaster
- Republicans to delay the election? Wulfgar
- mr. cranky, about the drums mia_wallace
- AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. Mr_Mucus
- The chick in this picture is pretty hot colonel_korn
- Well, "King Arthur" is about what you'd expect (spoilers) Drew_Atreides
- Shaq to go to the Miami Heat? Theodoric
- Our Entire Country Owes This Guy an Apology Coaster
- Hello there, party people. Eamon
- Man raised by chickens Dan_in_Cincinnati
- Why would anybody vote for this homophobic piece of shit? Throwing_Muses
- Kerry/Edwards takes a slight lead over Bush/Cheney Dan_in_Cincinnati
- The King of All Flip Flops Strikes Again!!!! fatburger
- People Mag, britney is finished. GTBurns
- Bloody new computer owners. daz
- THE LADDER THEORY... WESTERNIZED WOMEN VS FOREIGN WOMEN John_Doe
- I changed my mind. I can't see how Kerry can lose Aron
- I AM THE ALPHA AND THE OMEGA. John_Doe
- So i was watching "Star Wars" episodes I and II, the other day.. Drew_Atreides
- Lancelot.. what a fricking pussy! crystallynthegreat
- This board is even more political than I remember it being colonel_korn
- X-Man pRoDiGy
- Saw "the Terminal" (spoilers, maybe) Drew_Atreides
- Hwæt! Brush-up on your Anglo-Saxon! Billy_Z
- Saxons beating on drums- Billy_Z
- Now this is just childish. Xur
- The skankification of Angelina Jolie continues. Xur
- Bush Launches Broadside Against 'Pessimist' Edwards Xur
- Britney Spears' wedding registry. Xur
- BIG BROTHER FIVE Spanky
- my former teamate is going to the OLYMPICS! Grover
- Whoopi = Big Potty Mouth Spanky
- Jenna Bush campaigns for Dad Spanky
- French prisoner kills fellow inmate, eats his brains. Theodoric
- So anyway, there I was ... NoTimeToYodel
- AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. X-g-M
- I love my job. Becky_Sharp
- a few sorta new pics... daz
- AWESOME!!! Bush Impeachment OPEN BETA available to download. John_ Doe
- Awesome!!!! Star Trek: ConQuest beta available for download. Awesome!!!! John_ Doe
- Harold and Kumar go to White Castle Theodoric
- So what's the deal with White Castle anyways? colonel_korn
- Oh no. Theodoric
- Re: Harold and Kumar go to White Castle Mikoyan29
- Colonel Korn, White Castle burgers are called "sliders" . . . Hairhead
- White Castle burgers are classified as Biohazard 3 Throwing_Muses
- Back off, you pie floater-eatin' freak! :) Theodoric
- White Castle is mostly an urban thing, I think Mr_Happy_Face
- How is it different from a Krystal hamburger? Rajah
- Krystal's are supposed to be very similar Theodoric
- Like those A&W restaurants Rajah
- Wow. Xur
- They have both White Castle and Krystle at Krogers Rajah
- Dude, you don't actually eat them. Throwing_Muses
- Are sliders steam cooked? Dan_in_Cincinnati
- Yep, they are. Theodoric
- Nobody steamed cooked the Sliders MR_MUCUS
- This is your last warning, Muses! Theodoric
- Taste test :White Castle vs Krystal Rajah
- Well, if the burgers aren't your thing... Theodoric
- Chicken...... rings? Xur
- You know which part of the chicken they use to make chicken rings... Throwing_Muses
- Plot summary Xur
- Vegemite & Burger Rings! Throwing_Muses
- Hmmmm maybe they will taste different if they are heated up Rajah
- Hey, cool! Xur
- I first heard of White Castle in Beastie Boys songs MR_MUCUS
- White Castle is a sub-culture Dan_in_Cincinnati
- We have A&Ws Xur
- The best thing about WC's are the recipes fans send into the WC website! Yummy! sez Theodoric
- The old skool A&W drive-ins were way better Theodoric
- ooh, and here's a yummy WC casserole! Theodoric
- Great. A cardiac arrest in a casserole dish. Throwing_Muses
- -- from here to White Castle! Hold it now, HIT IT! Aron
- Honestly the name "Slyder" is pretty fucking gross colonel_korn
- Must have been thinking of the old A&W Rajah
- Holes JPBuckner
- White Castles are NOT sliders Nick-The-Knife
- In some cities, White Castle has teamed up with Church's Chicken Theodoric
- Jack in the Box Rajah
- White Castle and Jack in the Box Coaster
- & Colonel Korn Coaster
- I guess I shouldn't ask the diet is going then, Coaster MR_MUCUS
- Good Burgers in Vancouver, plus more White Castle info . . Hairhead
- By far the most disgusting is the Varsity Rajah
- If we are talking about the same Varsity, Rajah . . Hairhead
- They would have to have... Rajah
- Ah, yes, University memories . . . Hairhead
- Church's Chicken is disgusting Critico
- Popular Pedro... MR_MUCUS
- Mucus Critico
- Falsie advertising in King Arthur poster. 0b1knob
- I have the urge to kill women now... John_Doe
- If Bush is dumb on Iraq, Etc. Why are people in America still supporting hi John_Doe
- Michigan Republicans truly sink low Aron
- Free-Lance American-run Afghanistan "prison". Wulfgar
- Explosions Mikoyan29
- Death toll for coalition forces reaches the 1,000 mark Mr_Happy_Face
- Could Dubya back away from Kenny Boy any quicker? Throwing_Muses
- By far the most accurate depiction of King Arthur is..... Rajah
- Telephone numbers... The_Innocent_Bystander
- No exploding horsies??? daz
- FORUMS!!! archivist
- King "Arthur" M_H
- Fighting German knights on unstable ice? Theodoric
- Ha ha! Great review Cranky! Theodoric
- Glen Campbell wasn't drunk, he was just "over-served". Throwing_Muses
- tick tock tick tock... fatburger
|