|
 |
The Last Samurai
Mr. Cranky's rating:
When Cruise's final words are expelled from this 148-minute slug, it's like being released from jail.
If Tom Cruise makes any more movies like "The Last Samurai," people are going to start referring to him as the Rosie Ruiz of acting. Careless viewers may think he's accomplished something, but only because he's so literal in his presentation that they're forced to take cover as the typhoon of melodrama blows off the screen. Director Edward ("Glory") Zwick's and writer John ("Gladiator") Logan's film is the "Pearl Harbor" of Samurai movies. Political correctness doesn't even begin to describe the ground this film happily stampedes over. Capt. Nathan Algren (Cruise), feeling guilty about his role slaughtering Indians in the Civil War, accepts an assignment in Japan training an army to defeat Katsumoto (Ken Watanabe), an honorable Samurai warrior who's in the way of progress. After an initial battle goes awry, Algren is captured and develops a deep respect for the Samurai way of life. He spars with Katsumoto and falls in love with his sister, Taka (Koyuki), who returns the favor despite the fact that Nate previously plunged a sword through her husband's face. Oh, and white men make her sick, but she comes around because, you know, it's Tom Cruise. As everyone's honor begins to hinge on the emotional resonance of the spoken word, Logan's dialogue takes on the tone of a eulogy: The words are so leaden with meaning that they drop off the screen like anvils. Even worse is the climactic charge through cannonball fire which defies logic (cannons cannot adjust for distance quickly). When Cruise's final words are expelled from this 148-minute slug, it's like being released from jail.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "The Last Samurai" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "The Last Samurai" forum
Messages:
- The Last Samurai: The Phantom Menace rahimiiii
- Last Samurai deathtohollywooddogturds
- This movie is "Braveheart" means "Dances With Wolves" Homeboy
- was quite good to watch except for one thing....... JohnBoy19
- was quite good to watch except for one thing.... JohnBoy19
- was quite good to watch except for one thing JohnBoy19
- what do you get... The_Editor
- Actually.... morganlefey
- What kind of gun was that at the end of Last Samurai? . bellatrix27
- Some keanoid posted... daz
- The rest of you guys can stop now -- it's over Aron
- Why do women fake orgasms? Coaster
- I don't know about you, but THIS SCARES THE HELL OUT OF ME church
- USC as consensus #1 Scorsese_fan
- More "Cold Mountain" Scorsese_fan
- So, what do you guys think of Ed Zwick... Scorsese_fan
- Stupid. Fucking. Kids. Becky_Sharp
- This week's new movies Scorsese_fan
- X-Man is so ghey! PhuqYew
- Return of the King getting excellent early reviews... M_H
- It seems they wanna fingerprint me, and gimme some years X-MAN
- People bitching about pop-ups: http://toolbar.google.com/ X-MAN
- Poll: Who am I most unnecessarily too mean to? X-MAN
- The forums, meaning this forum, sucked this week MR_MUCUS
- DOJ fucks up anti-terrorism efforts. Again. Xur
- Erin Grey..<drools> MR_MUCUS
- Michael Moore admits America is dominated by sheep X-MAN
- Stupid criminal tricks Xur
- This movie was a cartoon at best. Grover
- I'm a pimp X-MAN
- Here I am..your rocket queeen X-MAN
- When I get on my knees and lick her hand, she screams. Anita_Bonghit
- I need help techies please Critico
- Wow, this movie's tracking "Vanilla Sky" almost exactly Scorsese_fan
- You know, the Ohio highway shootings just aren't as much fun... skilly
- Dogs of the world unite. Anita_Bonghit
- Oh_Dear_God_Make_It_Stop's Birthday is thursday. archivist
- Ed Gonzales trashes "Cold Mountain" Scorsese_fan
- What are your thoughts on Jersey Girl? Coaster
- Early box office projections Scorsese_fan
- POLL: use your imagination and help me out. Hellbilly
- Metacritic.com Scorsese_fan
- Anyone seen these 2 films? -- DVD Premiere Awards Scorsese_fan
- Diane Keaton best actress for "Something's Gotta Give"? Aron
- As if 'reality' television could not get any worse... church
- "Rocket Queen" is Guns & Roses greatest song. Hellbilly
- Has anyone else had that whacky pop-up that opens up all your disk drives? Hellbilly
- Last night's 24: last_angry_man
- Seattle okay's Elvis cabbies! Theodoric
- OUCH! Coaster Has His ASS Handed to Him by a Religious Conservative Coaster
- Crankyland Fantasy Football Playoffs!! Uber
- Playlist for yesterday's show Beast
- Short Samurai Poll Toady
- I think Gore has the right idea. Xur
- "the Rosie Ruiz of acting...." 0b1knob
- Hey i got my first Cranky's Hate Mail Critico
- You got my message! MR_MUCUS
- Tell him... ModernRonin
- I've only gotten one "hate mail" in six years here Theodoric
- Oh, and inform Ivan Theodoric
- My one true Crankyland hate mail... Aron
- Hell, Theo Coaster
- Shakira is a sell-out and has minimal talent. YageVines
- Shakira is really a pre-op tranny Theodoric
- Shakira is a no-good, talentless, pre-op tranny, jism-filled hack. church
- Um, church.... Theodoric
- No, Theo. church
- My mistake, then Theodoric
- No, but church
- Shakira has perianal lesions Anita_Bonghit
- I check my "real" email addy maybe once every million years... Mad-Ness_Monster
- Only one? Nick-The-Knife
- I'd probably still do Shakira if all that were true. MR_MUCUS
- Are you that hard up Mucus? church
- I take it you've tried both MR_MUCUS
- No church
- Okay, I looked up the lesions thing MR_MUCUS
- Nobody else watched Battlestar Galactica? (no spoilers) MR_MUCUS
- Fmr. Senator Paul Simon dies at 75 Theodoric
- Ohhhhhhhhh Uber, my boyfriend!!!! Remember my little visit with Santa? Gay-Conqueror
- AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. SIim_Shady
- Is "Monster" that good? Scorsese_fan
- Happy Holidays to all the snowed-in Mad-Ness_Monster
- Repost from below...how to protect your pc from spyware/popups/viruses/etc CorneliusD
- Clinton busted for drug possession... M_H
- Scumbag politician gets convicted for manslaughter Mr_Happy_Face
- I'm stuck in the middle on "Stuck On You" Aron
- Broom puts the smack down Xur
- Klaatu Barada Nikto Theodoric
- Some people in South Texas are hard up. PhuqYew
- Average Joe is the worst TV show in history. Cajunman
- Secretary of Soul & Foreign Minister of Funk appointed. Throwing_Muses
- Polls and Presidents Xur
- Goodbye, Crankyland, again. HomeSkillet
- German Vicar mistakenly distributes porn movie to congregation Theodoric
- Gore to endorse Dean? Theodoric
- Damn, the city sure is noisy. daz
- The problem is.... daz
- Peter Jackson might make The Hobbit. MR_MUCUS
- Hot or Not? Jeff_Probst
- OMG!!! daz
- happy birthday to my dog ivan! mia_wallace
- Ken, re: your essay Prince_Mongo
- "Cold Mountain" -- inspired by "TTRL"? Scorsese_fan
- * Cranky Contest! * Guess the ending of Ben Affleck's Paycheck Coaster
- The 2004 Bad Sex Award Mr_Happy_Face
- Ok, so I watched "Domestic Disturbance" last night... Scorsese_fan
- Newsweek's top 10 films of the year Scorsese_fan
- Box office #s: Cruise did die! Scorsese_fan
- That new Crystal Method song is rather catchy. just a little too sloooo-ooow!! Theodoric
- The French Army DarthGaul
- Cranky FFL: The Shadowculture homepage needs updating. Hellbilly
- YO YO I AM SLIM SHADY YO YO BLING BLNIG John_Doe
- "Last Samurai" was decent (possible spoilers) Drew_Atreides
- Hey Cranky you gotta get rid of some of your sponsers.. YageVines
- John Kerry f#$@s up Aron
- xur@xur.xur Xur
- History of BCS. gnosticdogma
- Art Basel Festival in Miami Beach? Dan_in_Cincinnati
- Crawling on her belly and shakin' like jelly Anita_Bonghit
- Purchased LOTR:TTT Extended uber-4-disc DVD jism edition. HomeSkillet
- Anyone else have this "spyware" thing pop up when they come to this site? Drew_Atreides
- Miss Hillary - pretty in pink Spanky
- Rocky Raccoon, Ranger Rick and the great Bourbon County Adventure. Anita_Bonghit
- gothica wasn't that great but... mia_wallace
- gosh it's getting nippy out here in so cal mia_wallace
- throwing_muses' Birthdayis Monday!!!!! <nt> archivist
- o.k., explain this one... Hellbilly
- The real Paris Hilton was on Weekend Update Aron
- That's why they play the game, Oklahoma. Aron
- I Took My Wife To Bad Santa 'Cause You Guys Said It Was Funny Coaster
- this movie kicked much ass! mia_wallace
- I saw this last night. HomeSkillet
- Washing a beard two or three times a day? gnosticdogma
- Trailer for Mel Gibson's Christ movie... M_H
- POLL - The five albums that you must own church
- OMG!!!! daz
- IGN trashes Sci-Fi's Battlestar Galactica miniseries MR_MUCUS
- Poll - worst puke inducing movie of all time Spanky
- Best piece of artwork ever (not gross) colonel_korn
- I don't know what's worse... Throwing_Muses
- This Film Was Awarded Two Bombs Too Many Coaster
- _Lord of the Rings_ Barbie Mad-Ness_Monster
- (Looks out window and just gapes...) Mad-Ness_Monster
- Went to a show Thursday Beast
- Just watched T3:Rise of the Machines. Throwing_Muses
- Abercrombie and Fitch accused of discriminating against 'ugly' people Theodoric
- Skilly's b-day is Sunday!!!! archivist
- Bush plans to send men back to the moon... M_H
- Maybe it's because I'm really fucking high... YageVines
- So i saw "Bad Santa" (possible spoilers) Drew_Atreides
- You know, I really like that Jet tune Theodoric
- Detroit Free Press critic says Honey is better than The Last Samurai MR_MUCUS
- From Heavy-Handed Symbolism Department... The_Innocent_Bystander
- Critico Xur
- Cocaine and Ecstasy part of a covert genetics experiment? Khan_Spearacy
- Does anyone know how I can find flu shots in my area? Emperorseth
- How to solve the Best Actor dilemma. HomeSkillet
- Well, "Bad Santa" completed its weekday sweep Scorsese_fan
- Pete Travers' (Rolling Stone) Top 10 movies Scorsese_fan
- POLL: THE LAST RECAP? Mr_Recap
- Who would win? gnosticdogma
- Forusm!!! 1/2 archivist
- Always put salt in your eye. Anita_Bonghit
- Movie Preferrence krquigley
- Somethingawful takes shot at AICN.com Slothrop
- Indie films saved by screener ruling Aron
- Becky, did you see this? jessica-renee
- Gone with the Wind HomeSkillet
- The Reagan dime Aron
- Samaurai Poll Mad-Ness_Monster
- Bush takes the coward's way out...again Mr_Happy_Face
- Grammy nominations Spanky
- In my mind I'm gone to Carolina... Ickyru
- Oh fuck no. Ninja Gaiden is gonna be extreme X-Doe-MAN
- Awesome!!!! Star Trek: ConQuest beta available for download. Awesome!!!! X-Doe-MAN
- Ahh, old toys. Becky_Sharp
- How will this film do? Scorsese_fan
- My cat's breath smells like poo TheAquabatman
- "Anita_Bonghit" is the worst fucking gimmick ever. colonel_korn
- Will someone please explain Mulholland Drive to me? Anita_Bonghit
- Today's fake SA is *hilarious* (Especially if you hate AICN) colonel_korn
- Can ya help a brother out? Scroticus
- ya know how sometimes black families name their kids names like "Latrelle" mendo
- The novel's Arwen - cardboard Mary Sue out of nowhere or subtle surprise? EmperorSeth
- Woman "trampled" at Wal-Mart actually a con artist? Theodoric
- Anita_Bonghit Craptacular
- Our government in action... Craptacular
- Rush is being singled out because he's conservative? Theodoric
- Paleolithic lobster penis found!!! Becky_Sharp
- You ought not done that to your boy. I studied on killing you. Anita_Bonghit
- C-Can it be?? Becky_Sharp
- The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly of Tom Cruise Theodoric
- It's all pretty ugly Craptacular
- Hmmm...? Scorsese_fan
- Cruise makes my skin crawl. Throwing_Muses
- Skin crawling... Scorsese_fan
- 'Top Gun' = gayest film ever made. Throwing_Muses
- Everyone I've met who saw Eyes Wide Shut did not like it MR_MUCUS
- MUCUS, why? Scorsese_fan
- Re: The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly of Tom Cruise PhuqYew
- I think because... Throwing_Muses
- The kinda people I know aren't substantive MR_MUCUS
- How the hell can you people forget the catasrophe that is church
- Scorsese_fan just my opinions Theodoric
- cocktail grievous-angel
- Hippy-hippy shake!! MR_MUCUS
- Yeah. Or as a friend of mine used to say Theodoric
- Interview with a Vampire = Gayest Movie Ever Moa_Kaka
- Say amen, Brother Theo...for Eyes Wide Shit... TheGodmother
- Nicole Kidman Craptacular
- Aren't we forgetting something? EmperorSeth
- Eyes Wide Shut HomeSkillet
- The problem with Vanilla Sky... HomeSkillet
- I didn't see MR, either Theodoric
- Phillip K. Dick keeps spinning.. YageVines
- Heyyyyyyy, I didn't forget Minority Report... PS: Homeskillet TheGodmother
- Theordoric... Scorsese_fan
- Godmother Scorsese_fan
- G'mom you forgot about me Critico
- I'm sorry to say it, but Days of Thunder is a guilty pleasure of mine... CorneliusD
- Eyes Wide Shut HomeSkillet
- Well... Scorsese_fan
- I've decided to stay away from this discussion Aron
- Sarah Vowell wrote a great article on Tom Cruise... Bickle
- Never understood the incredible dislike for Magnolia, either. Magnolia fan HomeSkillet
- "Magnolia" is okay, but Scorsese_fan
- By the way, Home Skillet... Scorsese_fan
- Two quotes from Tom Cruise films: Bickle
- S_F and Bickle HomeSkillet
- Wow. gnosticdogma
- Yeah, but... Scorsese_fan
- Magnolia is pretty much great all the way through. Throwing_Muses
- I loved Magnolia Critico
- Answers (w/out looking at other people's posts) Mad-Ness_Monster
- Magnolia is one of the worst films ever X-MAN
- X-MAN = John Doe X-Doe-MAN
- Katsumoto should have been played by Gedde Watanabe Tuning in Tokyo Theodoric
- To alcohol! The cause of, and solution to, Welfare_Cheese
- Women gets 10 yrs for running over McDonald's manager Theodoric
- I think I'd rather watch Yojimbo again, instead Theodoric
- Hari kari and combines... yes, I'm a New World Samurai Aron
- Indiana Jones and the Last Samurai Crusade Theodoric
- My Christmas Wish: AbsntMndedProf
- Hi all Craptacular
- secondsies Theodoric
- A firsties sweep! <nt> Emperorseth
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
|  |
|