Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
Mr. Cranky's rating:
Unfortunately, this is a story of Southern idiosyncrasies, guaranteed to dull your mind clean off.
I've got a message for all you little partners out there: a man's
got to know his limitations and apparently, Clint Eastwood doesn't. Read
my lips: instead of making my day with a short, pithy film about goofy
Southern people, Clint has gone off and made a boring epic (two-and-a-half
hours) based on the book by John Berendt. From his past experience, Clint
should have known better than anyone, choosing a way to begin, that's
easy, it's choosing a way to end that's the difficult thing to do.
Now, I know what you're wondering, did Clint overdo it by a lot, or
just a little? Well, to tell you the truth, in all the boredom, I forgot
myself. Unfortunately, this is a story of Southern idiosyncrasies,
guaranteed to dull your mind clean off. The question you have to ask
yourself about surviving this film is this: "Do I feel lucky?" Well, do
you, punk?
Based on true events, the story is as follows: a writer, John
Kelso (John Cusack) goes to Savannah, Georgia to write a story for "Town
and Country" on a Christmas party hosted by one of Savannah's most
prominent people, Jim Williams (Kevin Spacey). Seems like a simple task,
except Jim ends up shooting his lover, Billy Hanson (Jude Law), setting
off an investigation and forcing the town and its strange inhabitants to
come to grips with all the things they know but won't talk about.
Certainly, there's a darkness inside of all of us, but Southerners
seem to have the most idiotic ways of dealing with it. There's no question
that in a film like this, about characters, there's nothing wrong with
shooting, but the right people have to get shot. Following The Lady
Chablis (who plays herself) around for what seems like an eternity is
more than any person should have to take. Frankly, I have nothing nice to
say about this film; that's for other critics. They can crawl and kiss ass
and write the happy endings.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil" forum
Messages:
Public Apology to Jessalyn Leyra Karen_G
MITGOGAE faicoula
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil Susanne
BAD BAD BAD!!! (MajorTom)
Midnight with the Garden Weasel (Jack-Em-Up_JACKAL)
Midnight... (hawkeye)
A good place to start a new thread It would seem to me (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Ok (KTK)
Trollishness does not become you, KT King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
KT.... (jen)
JYD... (jen)
jen king (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Hmmmm.... (jen)
Let's see... King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Queen Mum (KTK)
Well, KT King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Well, Call Me Old Mother Hubbard, Then... No Queen Mum for (Mike_Ricci)
Welcome, Mike King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Which one is it today, Maggots? (Passion_Muffin)
Gosh, a new thread about pork rinds? (zeppo)
Not at all, Zeppo (Junk_Yard_Dog)
That's why you must give in to the dark side zeppo (Passion_Muffin)
Oh no! (Passion_Muffin)
Eye got an idea (Passion_Muffin)
Oh! It's *that* kind of thread.... (zeppo)
Awwwwww, MAN... (Mike_Ricci)
Ah, Yes! (Passion_Muffin)
Oops! (Passion_Muffin)
Passion, dearest To the rescue (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Well! (zeppo)
I hope you won't think me a hussy zeppo... (Passion_Muffin)
Ah, I see.... (zeppo)
Well, I’m perfectly willing to bring along Professor Housman (Philm_Phan)
Ah! It's the arduous Mrs. Phan.... (zeppo)
Sorry - always leave out those transitions (Philm_Phan)
I have... (jen)
Heh heh (Passion_Muffin)
Well, a lady of quality cannot be too chary of her reputation (Philm_Phan)
Guess I don't rate "normal", then? (zeppo)
Well, it was mostly harmless (Philm_Phan)
Wasn’t kidding (Philm_Phan)
Ms Phan King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Just a few days ago going through some old basement threads King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Trolling is no fun (Pvt_Gump)
Confused? (zeppo)
Zeppo (Pvt_Gump)
You were going to post as Joshua? (Philm_Phan)
Ah I remember the good old days (KTK)
Bloke (jen)
Now, now people..... (Pvt_Gump)
Well... (jen)
Ouch, KTK (Philm_Phan)
re: Neal (jen)
Gump (KTK)
Oh, I know, KTK (Philm_Phan)
I remember when Dr. Empirical jumped on KT. (zeppo)
Well, maybe in real life he was that way (Philm_Phan)
"I'm sorry, but your time's up." (zeppo)
“This isn’t an argument.” (Philm_Phan)
zep (KTK)
So what IS the nature of friendship - (Philm_Phan)
KT, there may have been two threads. (zeppo)
I'm pretty sure... (jen)
KTK (Pvt_Gump)
Actually, there was a long period - (Philm_Phan)
Hey PP! (jen)
KZS, KSZ... geez (Philm_Phan)
Speaking of which, Mrs. P..... (zeppo)
Did you know - (Philm_Phan)
zeppo... (jen)
PP.. (jen)
Yeah, I always thought that was an unfair tactic, zep (Philm_Phan)
Yes, you’re right, jen (Philm_Phan)
I also heard a good one from Bluebird. (zeppo)
Did you send me the question via e-mail, zep? (Philm_Phan)
Yep. (zeppo)
Zeppo.. (jen)
I remember! (zeppo)
That's right! (jen)
I know the feeling jen King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Is this... (KTK)
Oh God, not De Lancie, is it? (Philm_Phan)
PP (KTK)
*I* remember Miss Nomer. (zeppo)
You Silly Willys! (Wargasm)
Wow, that doesn't sound like Dr. E. (zeppo)
Oooooh, I know.... (Wargasm)
zep (Wargasm)
Man... (Mike_Ricci)
Wow Yes, I blew it (Junk_Yard_Dog)
That was before your time JYD (Passion_Muffin)
I heard of the rumored Hamlet thread King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Spill Wargasm (KTK)
OK, NOW I AM ANNOYED!!! (KTK)
KT The stupid (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Not to mention - (Philm_Phan)
JYD?!?!?! (jen)
You do feel violated - (Philm_Phan)
p.s. JYD (Philm_Phan)
me car (KTK)
BTW (KTK)
Quick, everyone! (Philm_Phan)
Yup, you did make me smile (NT) (KTK)
OK, so now I am REALLY REALLY ANNOYED (KTK)
You have locks on your boots? (zeppo)
zeppo’s right (Philm_Phan)
Maybe this is it. (zeppo)
jen The caught (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Ms. Phanny The curious (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Ok, coppers... Out in a blaze (Junk_Yard_Dog)
So, Mr JYD... (TheDA)
Elusive ? (Wolfman)
Luckily... (KTK)
Boy, KTK - (Philm_Phan)
Philm Phan (Wolfman)
Yeah, I wondered about that. (zeppo)
Well, if one’s not permitted some senile confusion - (Henry_Carr)
We're mired in warm weather Waiting for fall (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Someone say they were stuck in time? (TheDoctor)
Did someone say jelly babies? (KTK)
Re: A good place to start a new thread (Ivan_Leopold)
Is that DESTINY OF THE DALEKS, KTK? (Philm_Phan)
Welcome, Ivan The confessing (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Despite many rumors to the contrary (Ivan_Leopold)
Huh... (Lionel_Cosgrove)
Oh yeah, one more thing: (Lionel_Cosgrove)
Jelly babies (roo)
Roo King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
bugger (KTK)
I think Davros must have destroyed it... (KTK)
Now that IS a hilarious image, KTK (Philm_Phan)
All quiet on the evil front (Ivan_Leopold)
New topic of discussion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (Pvt_Gump)
Wow King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Cosgrove on cable: "The Vampire Journals" (Lionel_Cosgrove)
I finally wake up from my stupor (drthompson)
My dear Doctor (KTK)
Wouldn't you prefer (Joshua_)
Joshua (KTK)
Chess is good, but it's... (Wolfman)
But Joshua, (Ivan_Leopold)
Come on, Joshua! (Philm_Phan)
But why do we have to be ourselves (Threadkiller)
Only three, darlings? (Margot_Beste-Chetwynde)
If I could... (Lionel_Cosgrove)
Wolfman (KTK)
Playing (Wolfman)
Wolf (KTK)
Ah, Lionel (Philm_Phan)
KT... (Wolfman)
French-made? (Philm_Phan)
A well made maid ? (Wolfman)
Since this is the Garden of Good and Evil (Joshua_)
Got a question for you, Joshua (Threadkiller)
Threadkiller (Joshua_)
Absolutely! (Stephen_Falken)
We should leave here. (Papa_Hemingway)
I hadn’t noticed Oscar here, had you? (Philm_Phan)
If you're a college student (Threadkiller)
Sigh -- ignore above post (Threadkiller)
Pull up a chair and pour a glass, TK (Philm_Phan)
Don't know where everybody else is... (Threadkiller)
I worked last night I like Joshua (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Ah! Another one! And I like Mike_Ricci (Threadkiller)
Nope -- it's in the Sleepy Hollow thread. (NT) (Threadkiller)
Thread Killer, about those engineering students (Pvt_Gump)
Sorry. (Papa_Hemingway)
It's been a while..... (zeppo)
Hmmmm A curious (Junk_Yard_Dog)
It was that damn drunk Hemingway (Lionel_Cosgrove)
I take exception to that, Sir! (RichardBrinsleySheridan)
Re: A good place to start a new thread King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Re: A good place to start a new thread (Threadkiller)
Mike King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Jagr (Mike_Ricci)
Nice try, Mike King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Oh... (Mike_Ricci)
Hey -- Guess Who Got Three Points Yesterday... (Mike_Ricci)
JYD -- Did You Hear the Bad News? (Mike_Ricci)
Yep King (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Woohoo... let me in the party! Sir (Fatty_McGee)
Fatty (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Hey Junky (Nicky)
Welcome, Nicky (Junk_Yard_Dog)
I saw that one (Nicky)
Hey JYD! (Homeboy)
As far as I know... (Threadkiller)
JYD (Nicky)
Well, Nicky (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Thank you (Nicky)
Just try not to tread on anybody's toes... (Threadkiller)
re: ls and sonof (Fatty_McGee)
Fatty (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Tsk-tsk (Lady_Orlando)
Lady Orlando (Nicky)
Junky (Nicky)
Nicky (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Nicky, I am posting this AMD stuff here, cause my last post crashed.... (Pvt_Gump)
Sharks Trade Mike Vernon... (Mike_Ricci)
Yes! Another one ripe for the plucking! (Threadkiller)
vacant (bucket)
Midnight... (prrlz)
The gnosticdogma/Discord dialogs, Part 6 "Idiots". (gnosticdogma)
What a Waste of a Perfectly Good Spacey (Giuseppe)
WRONG!! I beg to differ... (Lysernix)
This movie is so boring I can't hardly believe it! (bored)
Midnight in the Garden of Dullness and Boredom (vanity)
My personal thoughts on this movie... (Pandora)
It wasn't just the fact that they screwed up the book... (Fletch)
MR CRANKY? GET THE HOOK!! (ed hamada)
A movie about nothing (N.J.)
JOHN CUSACK IS Soooooooo h0t!!!!! (john cusack fan)
Let me begin by saying I wasted a fistful of dollars... (Bronco Brian)
Just a reminder (in case anyone sees this through all the SOS crap)... (Eamon J. Doyle)
Symbolism (DigMe)
Killer Dwarf(spoiler) (Beast)
Midnight in the Garden of Bad and Worse (sarah)
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!