Music and Lyrics
Mr. Cranky's rating:
It's like bringing a puppy home from the pound and marveling at its cuteness until the moment it defecates on your favorite rug.
Something awful happens in the middle of "Music and Lyrics," the newest romantic comedy from writer/director Marc ("Two Weeks Notice") Lawrence. It's like bringing a puppy home from the pound and marveling at its cuteness until the moment it defecates on your favorite rug.
In this film, it's that moment when the novelty of making fun of '80s pop singers, of which Alex Fletcher (Hugh Grant) is one, wears off and the realization that there's not much holding the movie together begins. It's also the point you begin to notice the way the scenes are structured and the interminable length of some of them. There are actually moments in the movie where you'd swear the actors are waiting for the director to yell cut. In fact, this may be Lawrence's gift to the world: the ability to convey the reality that conversations go nowhere, stop suddenly, and often don't restart quite right or at all. It's a reality that we only become aware of when somebody is bothering us by pointing it out.
That Alex and Sophie Fisher (Drew Barrymore) ever meet is sort of a lark. Alex has the opportunity to write a song for the latest teen pop sensation, Cora Corman (Haley Bennett), but has no confidence as a lyricist. Enter Sophie, who's only in Alex's apartment to water the plants. After some idle chatter, Alex realizes that Sophie is his lyricist and they begin working on the song prompting an immediate epiphany by any audience member with a double digit IQ that they've become the "Music and Lyrics" of the title and are destined for couplehood.
The main question I had after this set-up was this: Are there people who actually make a living watering plants? Sophie is just filling in for Alex's regular plant lady. Her real job is working with her sister (Kristin Johnston) in their family's weight-loss business. Okay, I'm sure if you're rich you have plant ladies and butt wipers and whatever other kind of slave substitute one can imagine, but Alex isn't exactly rolling in the dough and seems perfectly capable of watering his own damn plants.
There's something about the film's thin, semi-serious commentary on today's pop idols -- embodied in Cora -- that I find nauseating. Cora's commercialized religion is just annoying enough to be funny but not offensive enough to make anybody think about its wider implications. Sure, it's not a movie's job to do such things, but there's an innocuousness there that disturbs me.
"Music and Lyrics" is not much different from many of the forgettable '80s pop tunes it ridicules.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Music and Lyrics" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "Music and Lyrics" forum
Messages:
Music and Lyrics Elisa
Testing Agrula
Please God - no interpretive dance numbers of the five best picture films The_Third_Nipple
The O.C. finale... it's over. sonofthedummy
Someone must've fed Dick Cheney after midnight. sonofthedummy
Flaregun material. ModernRonin
Jen Mal_Content
Another one claims to be the father of Anna Nicole's Baby.... Bobo
Environment is no longer in jeopardy with Hollywood making a sacrifice The_Third_Nipple
HA HA! -- http://i17.tinypic.com/2h73ukl.jpg TMundo
The People who are Typecast to Play, "Assholes," in Movies Thread TMundo
Must we wear pants at LBG's wedding? RidingFool
Shocking news flash X-Man
The Prestige X-Man
Best Picture - what's it gonna be? HomeSkillet
Oh-oh. Better black out those clown shoes! RidingFool
American-Seacrest-Idol-out! Week 1. sonofthedummy
Why can't I stop hearing the "fight" between A-Rod and Jeter as... sonofthedummy
Drug dealer leaning into car window gets bisected when customer drives away Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Concert time again. Neurotic_Chap
Passengers Bill of Rights LittleBigGirl
Anna Nichol Smith to star in upcoming zombie movie Rajah
"Maverick" John McCain disses VP; Cheney snaps back convenor
Hallelujah! Thank God for Flatulence! LittleBigGirl
what do you think part2 oscarjunk25
What woman could resist this guy! X-Man
Geffen pissis off the Clintons Spanky
Anyone else here predict a late surge for Peter O'Toole as Best Actor? HomeSkillet
Is Brittany going to set off a new fad? Rajah
Hillary Clinton is gonna make us fall in love with her all over again Rajah
Jetblu airlines must have killed thousands! X-Man
My invisible gun X-Man
MLB to change player caps to synthetic material? sonofthedummy
Deadly Cheeseburger? LittleBigGirl
If George W Chimp wrote his own State of the Union Address Dan_in_Cincinnati
Dax Flame teaches you how to do cool movie moves! X-Man
It's a shoe-in! RidingFool
Next president of the United States X-Man
London mayor signs oil deal with Chavez! MR_MUCUS
White House: Moles taken from Bush's face benign Shakesmear
President Rush Limbaugh & Vice President Ann Coulter Spanky
Eating meat causes more global warming than driving. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
To sum: Prime Mover
I dunno, I feel pretty good X-Man
Thinking about having lots of kids? LittleBigGirl
2006 Crankyland Movie Awards ballot Aron
Prince Harry to go to Iraq Rajah
John Murtha finds a way to bring some troops back from Iraq Dan_in_Cincinnati
FUCK THE AIRLINES Xur
Now, if they could breed turkeys like this RidingFool
Al Gore pwns Bender! sonofthedummy
Scrotum scrotum scrotum!!! Mad-Ness_Monster
What to do about this year's Crankyland Movie Awards? Aron
So I was watching G-string divas last night and... Mr_Nonsense
Can't wait for the mugshot............. Bobo
Had a dream about Lincoln and a beaver last night Rajah
Jennifer (Loni Anderson) in Cincinnati Dan_in_Cincinnati
Arizona legislator tries to keep teachers from voicing opinions on issues M_H
Any JetBlue fans on here? sonofthedummy
Daytona 500, Toytoa did poorly (shocker!) sonofthedummy
Riding Fool: Chica
Why is there no thread re Bald Britney's breakdown? Throwing_Muses
Just saw Letters from Iwo Jima: should be best picture of 2006 Ickyru
umm hello! DMagic000
Muslim cleric says something stupid shockah. Throwing_Muses
A quote from my mom: jen
Has anyone not experienced the glory of the "George Washington" song? Mad-Ness_Monster
Here's some neat ads. MAYORBOB
Dan_in_Cincinnati
US Doing Better Than its Kyoto Critics on CO2, Expert Says Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Some things never change. Homeboy
Nader in '08? Dan_in_Cincinnati
Conqueror found, a year after death, in front of TV. Throwing_Muses
I think this movie is made of something special! The_Onionhuff
This movie was so goddam adorable OneBouncingSoul
Report from the Wildlife Center... jen
There is justice in this world. Omega_Man
Finally saw ALL of "Donnie Darko" last night... jen
Aren't you tired of being abducted by aliens? Rajah
Do want have googlepack or firefox installed llamasex
Haw-haw! sonofthedummy
Does Anybody Else Want To Have Sex With Anna Nicole Smiths Autopsied Body? DarthGaul
"Bored on a Friday Night" Myspace survey.... jen
80's Music!!! Mad-Ness_Monster
Week 4/16 - What I Learned Mad-Ness_Monster
Just how irresponsible are you? The_Innocent_Bystander
Hit themute button for a minute! RidingFool
For Seattle Area Crankizens the_demon
For Riding Fool Rajah
DAX FLAME!!! X-Man
Fantasy baseball Junk_Yard_Dog
Frank White can't stop shooting at a guy that's already dead... TMundo
U.S. State Deparment takes 7 weeks to tell me thnink don't think I'm me! sonofthedummy
Cranky Fantasy Baseball Uber
Texas Congressman believes Earth doesn't revolve around sun... M_H
Music and Lyrics TRIVIA: Who wrote The Banana Boat Song (Day-O)? Coaster
Will Al Franken make a good senator? Rajah
As quoth Harrison Ford :"Get off my plane!" sonofthedummy
Would embalming Anna Nichol Smith Rajah
Large squid lights up for attack Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Cranky: Have you sold this web-site? Prime Mover
Toys are not a right in Georgia RidingFool
Regarding that wedding countdown business... LittleBigGirl
Sinners. RidingFool
And, RidingFool
Not into big weddings, either... jen
Maybe, if the beach was in Tahiti mangy-ranger
Want to keep the wedding simple? Coaster
Bad plan, Coaster mangy-ranger
You guys are too funny. LittleBigGirl
WTF? Rajah
not surprised at the fact that someone knows what a Betazoid is on here. sonofthedummy
heh, mangy... Slothrop
Coaster = Trekkie Rajah
Damn, Sloth... jen
jen, I may claim many things... Slothrop
What kind of a man starts a wedding counter? Drew_Atreides
Okay, I hate to do this, Drew, but... jen
"What kind of man starts wedding counter?" LittleBigGirl
Studies show people who live together first are more likely to get divorced X-Man
Does he buy your tampons for you, too? <nt> Slothrop
When necessary, yes. Unlike Sloptrap, he's secure in his masculinity. LittleBigGirl
Well, he's more of a man than I am. Rajah
Two threads in three weeks equals stalking... Slothrop
Considering how often LBG posts these days Rajah
Tampons! Shit! RidingFool
Congrats, LBG! the_demon
I went to a wedding near the Wichita Mountains. MR_MUCUS
Crampons! Forgot to pick some of those up! sonofthedummy
Hi, Little Big Girl! The_Little_General
I guy who sets a counter, buys tampons AND is happy to watch you belch? Drew_Atreides
Ha Drew! Coaster
Yes, well... jen
Hey, LBG, you know what would be neat... Junk_Yard_Dog
Of course, to make the reception real simple.... Junk_Yard_Dog
JYD.... question: jen
Does Kumar have no meaning for you Junk_Yard_Dog
I'm going to lunch with my best friend and her baby today Critico
Women say they want sensitive, caring, loving men... Mr_Nonsense
Nah, I want to have my cake and eat it too. LittleBigGirl
But to be perfectly serious... LittleBigGirl
Sooo...being interested in sports is a required condition. Mr_Nonsense
I continue to look RidingFool
Tall, over 26... Mr_Nonsense
So Drew... G Spot Tornado
Haha! Drew_Atreides
Hey, Drew Junk_Yard_Dog
Drew G Spot Tornado
Yes. Drew_Atreides
You know... jen
Jen, the gist of it as i recall: Drew_Atreides
This isn't about... jen
One point: Drew_Atreides
Oh, okay... jen
Go fish. RidingFool
Drew, you argued against disallowing people with disabilities to go to Mal_Content
Someone, please fill me in... Mal_Content
I wish i could say i want to recall where that thread is.. Drew_Atreides
That post was by Slater. And G-Spot is fucked in the head. Coaster
Mal, to answer your question... jen
PS to Drew jen
ooops jen
Drew, you screeched like a howler monkey G Spot Tornado
The theaters are full of mental retards. What's a few more? RidingFool
I hate the things. Mr_Nonsense
Umm...since when do the "rights" of the disabled need to be debated? Mal_Content
btw, Drew, congrats on your wedding... Mal_Content
Retard_In_The_Theater, classic troller handle. MR_MUCUS
Mr. M jen
Thank you, Mal. <nt> Drew_Atreides
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
Kung hei fat choi. Throwing_Muses
Jennifer Lopez = Humanitarian Spanky
"re there people who actually make a living watering plants? " The_Third_Nipple
Jen, you've got mail... Mal_Content
Firsties Mal_Content
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "Music and Lyrics " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!