Norbit
Mr. Cranky's rating:
Will fat people ever find their Martin Luther King?
Will fat people ever find their Martin Luther King?
Seriously, how much more abuse are fat people going to take before they get together and march on Hollywood to demand equal treatment under the MPAA? Beyond its potential to start a tsunami of a political movement, the prospect of a "million fat march" should be a matter of national concern as it will likely also devastate all crops and food stores in its path. But seriously, who among the oppressed obese will finally stand up to the ridicule, and before the hushed mob on Hollywood and Vine rise up and say, firmly and with righteous conviction: "I have… an ice cream."
See? It's just too easy. I can't help it. I have… a theme: It's open season on the obese, and in "Norbit" Eddie Murphy takes full advantage of every easy potshot in sight. It's the humor equivalent of one of those "hunting parks" full of birds that have already had their wings clipped (the ones that Dick Cheney seems to be so fond of).
Perhaps the craziest thing about a film where the male star cross-dresses as a fat, outrageous black woman is that it's already been done ("Big Momma's House"). Twice. ("Diary of a Mad Black Woman.") Perhaps Murphy thought that the previous films didn't fully plumb the emotional complexity the genre had to offer. Or perhaps he knew box-office would increase from Google searches for "Eddie Murphy and cross-dressing." Either way, he dives right in, playing geeky Norbit, his horrible obese wife Rasputia and walking Asian caricature Mr. Wong. Thandie Newton plays Norbit's startlingly thin soul mate.
The plot is simple: Fat women are mean, disgusting and evil. Thin women are beautiful, kind and deserving of twice the love. And if Thandie Newton is any indication, the thinner the better. She's not just thin; she's starvation thin, wasting-disease thin, Rex-Grossman-Super-Bowl-legacy thin. You spend most of her scenes wondering if she'll faint in the hot sun or blow away in a stiff breeze. It's seriously distracting. Not that Mr. Cranky would throw her out of bed for eating crackers. Let's get real here.
However, casting the ridiculously thin Netwon as the counterweight to the ridiculously obese Rasputia makes it seem like the film is going beyond a simple comedy to underscore the point that fat people are unredeemable and should just throw themselves in front of a speeding bus, killing themselves and everyone in the bus in the process. I'm not sure whether to laud this film or revile it for refusing to add the tiniest shred of PC garnish to that harsh message.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Norbit" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "Norbit" forum
Messages:
Al Gore's 24hr 'save the earth' concert not to be called Alapalooza. Throwing_Muses
NEW CULTURE WAR Mr_Cranky
A quick lesson in fiat currency for Xman and Lance. ModernRonin
Countdown to the wedding! LittleBigGirl
Culture War Articles Mr_Cranky
New comedy show! Preview it here! RidingFool
Watch Vista's voice-recognition software in action! RidingFool
Gong Li rules! Spanky
The bump key: Open 90% of locks easily. X-Man
\/\/ Look at all these x-man posts! Even responding to himself! \/\/ Ben-Dover-69
Tim Hardaway said some harsh things about gays X-Man
THIS VIDEO IS AWFUL X-Man
Rajah said he wasleaving btw X-Man
Guess Ben Dover didn't have a date on Valentines day X-Man
No caption winners yet (Wed, 11:40PM EST)? Are they that bad? sonofthedummy
Why not to audition for American Idol. sonofthedummy
Here's the best chick I've found on youtube X-Man
America's Debate LittleBigGirl
TMundo's Bizzare but You've got nothing Else to do Youtube Thread TMundo
COASTER! The_Innocent_Bystander
Poll predicts 2008 White House run will look like 2001 Senate race in NY. sonofthedummy
The I'm Spending Valentines Day Alone So Fucking What Thread TMundo
Will an jonest Bush supporter tell me why we have a chance in Iran? TMundo
Mitt Romney says Homeland Security Spanky
Utah killer was a Muslim Spanky
X-Man/Captain Lance Mr_Cranky
meatloaf... jen
House hearing on 'Warming of the planet" canceled after ice storm Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Bruce Campbell is the man. Drew_Atreides
Hobo Heartgrams Rajah
Happy Love Day jen
Fuck it all to hell! Rajah
Look at these crazy radiant silvergun videos X-Man
Air America to be auctioned off, declares bankruptcy yet again X-Man
I'm thinking of changing my screenname X-Man
So, x-mans spammed up the boards with another week of worthless crap Ben-Dover-69
So, we're going to invade Iran right? X-Man
So Obama said soldiers lives in Iraq=wasted X-Man
"Country radio wont forgive Dixie Chicks" lol X-Man
OK, who gave X-Man a grenade??? Xur
NYC Metro area set to receive 1"-3" of snow... sonofthedummy
al-Zawahri saz Bush is "an alcoholic and a lying gambler". Throwing_Muses
X, are you there? Wanna cheer me up? jen
Look at this idiot game developer X-Man
Libertarian blogger advocates gov't assassination convenor
LADIES! Are you tired of your man running off? Well, gone no more! RidingFool
This should've been done a long time ago!!! sonofthedummy
Okay, so everyone can keep track of my exercise... jen
Columbine, Mormon style Aron
X-Man jen
Tibron. Not_LRT
NOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Rajah
FIVE RANDOM BOOK TITLES I CAN SEE FROM HERE: Not_LRT
Actually... TMundo
This Valentines Day, take her to a movie that'll scar you both for life TMundo
Arnold Shwartzenaegger? TMundo
Scientist invents relatively cheap cure for global warming. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Little Miss Sunshine -- Haphazerdly shuffled together scenes. TMundo
New excuse when caught napping by the boss! sonofthedummy
John McCain is having flashbacks... sonofthedummy
Ségolène Royal. She's French, she's socialist and she's hot. Throwing_Muses
FIVE RANDOM WORDS FROM THE DICTIONARY: Not_LRT
Why did Eddie Murphy take the character special effects thing too far? TMundo
Dracula on PBS Omega_Man
The question I always wanted to ask Anna Nicole Smith Aron
So why no "Hannibal Rising' review? The_Third_Nipple
Rosie O'donnell is claiming to be the father of Nicole's baby. Bobo
An excellent article mia_wallace
2 Arrested During Support March Of Border Agents mia_wallace
Ever wondered about the beer goggle effect? RidingFool
Gong Li rules in Hannibal Rising!!!!! Spanky
P.M. Howard stay out of our politics! Rajah
Dixie Chicks, five Grammys, Toby Keith, zero Mr_Happy_Face
Geeks on youtube.... sonofthedummy
If Iraq = Vietnam, then... sonofthedummy
Gay statue at Hoover Dam Rajah
I forgot to post of my day at the Wildlife Center... jen
U.S. Mint has too much time on it's hands... sonofthedummy
Holy Crap! This "Norbit" piece of shit is number 1! sonofthedummy
Canada sets a civilized Post-9/11 example . . Hairhead
Thank you Mr. Schwarzenegger!!!!!!!! You're my hero! mia_wallace
Ah even the bears are for romance... oops, maybe not! sonofthedummy
Finally saw "The Depawted...er...The Departed" MR_MUCUS
Niger's people and environment benefit from adopting private property. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
An interesting op-ed on the failures of our military Xur
Finally got to meat Mrs. Coaster! Rajah
Family Values? sonofthedummy
States to Bush: Go F*** yourself on National Driver's license Dan_in_Cincinnati
Flaming hypocrite John McCain Taps Cash He Sought To Limit Dan_in_Cincinnati
Holy shit! Cranklyland lives! Hellbilly
Don't Give in To Hallmark LittleBigGirl
110 inches of snow in 7 days... The_Innocent_Bystander
Where's Eamon? Xur
You Want Love On Valentine's Day? Blackbeard
Perfect valentines for the dysfunctional couple... Mal_Content
School knowingly allows student to rape multiple students. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
"Thank you veddy much, Jerry!" LittleBigGirl
Is it just me or is Bush not trying anymore? sonofthedummy
CRAVE ansers a question Coaster
Obama announcing the obvious later today... sonofthedummy
Ian Richardson Dead (you'll know who he is) sonofthedummy
Zombie Anna Nicole Blackbeard
Abuse of prisoners was common in Iraq Dan_in_Cincinnati
23 with Jim Carrey looks pretty cool X-Man
Canada set to destroy it's economy if it adopt Kyoto X-Man
Canada has conservative government. ex-man = dumbass + owned again. Throwing_Muses
The conservatives are trying to stop the destruction of Canada's economy X-Man
Eat Duffy
Climate change is the boondoggle of the century, akin to the Y2K bullshit RidingFool
Seems pretty stupid if Blair is refusing to trade credits Oh_Dear_God_Make_It_Stop
Boondoggle? michael3b
Al Gore says sea level will rise 20 feet by the year 2100. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Here's the NASA sataellite data on global temperatures. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Environmentalists have a history of making bogus doomsayer predictions. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Compared to other countries, U.S. energy policy is a joke. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Not interested in what extremists on either side have to say. michael3b
Bjørn Lomborg has a doctorate in political science. He is not a scientist. Throwing_Muses
So, global warming isn't real Mr_Happy_Face
Throwing Muses Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Mr Happy Face Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Pressurized water nuclear reactor = zero pollution. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
The biggest cause of global warming is irrational opposite to more nuclear Captain_Lance_Murdoch
X-Man, Baird's words are simply scare tactics. Mal_Content
Bjørn of Lomborg just wants to assimilate Earth. MR_MUCUS
Wow, Mr. Mucus. That was so weird, I can't even think of a response? Mal_Content
He's partying his ass off in Vega$ RidingFool
That's this weekend? Mal_Content
I love this idea from Al Gore and Richard Branson! Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Didn't you post this last week? Mal_Content
Do try to keep up with the rest of the class, grundle. Throwing_Muses
Al Gore has a degree in political science. He is not a scientist. You_People_Are_Silly
He also has a keen interest in the preservation of our planet. Mal_Content
Yeah, Mal, all the other spammers are in Vega$ RidingFool
Oh, and... RidingFool
"Didn't you post this last week?" hee hee! Rajah
She is? And I thought she was just another CnarkyLand troll... RidingFool
Mal is the new "It Girl" in Crankland! Rajah
Catfight between who, Rajah? jen
oh, I forgot Nessie... jen
ickyru is a guy NT Critico
Well, stopping catfights ain't one of them Rajah
ooops, I thought for sure that... jen
Should finish my thought... jen
Yeah thanks Rajah
Sorry I wrote it Rajah
me, too, raj. jen
PS.... jen
My fault Rajah
Rajah... jen
You mean she's not your bitch? Rajah
Rajah... jen
Oh....I thought you were saying Rajah
No, Rajah jen
The old "It Girl" was MUCUS Rajah
Will you bitches stop arguing! RidingFool
<bitch slaps Riding Fool> Rajah
oh jen
You were the it, girl. Mr_Nonsense
The meaning seems to be evolving Rajah
Well, I sure can't argue with that fact there... jen
I truly am embarassed, tho. jen
No reason to feel embarrassed Rajah
Have you guys gone completely fucking insane? Mal_Content
Oh no, Mal, sweetie... jen
I can't speak for the others Rajah
Clara Bow was the original "It Girl". RidingFool
I'm changing it to "That Girl" Rajah
Oh, and thanks, Jen... Mal_Content
me too Rajah
I apologize Mal Rajah
Mal jen
PS jen
Each unto their nature Rajah
So, are you saying now... jen
No, drop it already Rajah
All dropped... jen
Drop Kick Me Jesus Through The Goalposts Of Life RidingFool
Riding Fool, I was deeply offended by what you just wrote! Rajah
Keee-rist. Can't a fella even sing a few bars in here any more? RidingFool
hee hee Rajah
I would feel much better if everyone would please drop this conversation Mal_Content
one last thought.... jen
Re: Canada set to destroy it's economy if it adopt Kyoto vikrantsuri
virgin earth challenge vikrantsuri
Snorebit sonofthedummy
Hmm, Rummy's long gone and yet the DoD sounds even nuttier... sonofthedummy
Je suis le chasseur You_People_Are_Silly
Xie? Still here? jen
Today I came to the slow realization... Mad-Ness_Monster
But Nessie jen
even though I've been thinking of asking someone out... sonofthedummy
Not only is it too commercial, it's also really annoying. Mal_Content
Restuarant here is doing "Blindfolded" Dinners $90 a head! sonofthedummy
This sounds idiotic to me... Mal_Content
I just realized.. Drew_Atreides
Drew Atreides and Aron/CFL have slowly morphed into almost the same poster X-Man
Now, wait a minute, Drew... jen
Okay, I'll share my sad V-Day stories... jen
Stupid holiday Marion
Sounds to me like they're all tramps anyway. RidingFool
I CAN'T BELIEVE y'all don't understand the true meaning of Valentine's Day Coaster
Mal, date only men who are self assured enough to say this to pushy people Coaster
I've thought that more then once, Xie.. Drew_Atreides
"eye opening" Xur
Eyeopening. Blackbeard
Valentine's Day Blows! Mal_Content
The dearth of romance in this forum RidingFool
Romance isn't dead. Mal_Content
*smears self in Vichyssoise, crème brûlée, chocolat, et livres* RidingFool
I don't mind romance on V-Day.. jen
I'd be all over you, but... Mal_Content
Aw.... darn... jen
V-day's not for me. Mal_Content
I don't recall you saying anything about slathering yourself in chocolate! Mal_Content
Romance isn't dead... Xur
Well... jen
The Vichyssoise RidingFool
I forgot to ask which books you were smothered in... Mal_Content
No Xur
Actually, I'm dyslexic. RidingFool
XUR! The_Innocent_Bystander
You seem to be handling your handicap quite well.. Mal_Content
Yes Xur
Xur! jen
I meant you & She... jen
Not that you're not worth hitting on or anything... jen
Thanks jen Xur
That's cool, xur jen
I was hoping the realization was... MR_MUCUS
No, that was a good pun Rajah
I'VE GOT THE MATCH FOR YOU. . . Not_LRT
Actually, I'm starting to lose my "underage charisma" Aron
You still have that midget cachet going for you Rajah
Lost "underage charisma"..like Michael J. Fox. Mr_Nonsense
I have a date! Critico
Who hasn't slept with Anna Nicole Smith? Blunt
Here's a new Duff pic (Feb 8) she been working out X-Man
Pimped out Toilet fulfils your wildest, errr, dreams... TMundo
Watched some of Crank X-Man
Nancy Pelosi demands huge jet while chairing global warming panel X-Man
Richard Branson & Al Gore want YOU to save the world! Throwing_Muses
Things I learned during Practicum Week 3/16 Mad-Ness_Monster
So much for that "mild" winter.... sonofthedummy
Are these guys nuts? sonofthedummy
Cranky was too hard on Rex Grossman... sonofthedummy
Bush Official's Key Report On Iraq Is Faulted Dan_in_Cincinnati
Mr Cranky = 'Irony-laden femme bot.' Prime Mover
Jeb Bush calls Obama "articulate", murders bimbo in Hollywood. michael3b
Vickie Lynn Hogan dead at 39. 0b1knob
The finest healthcare in the world! RidingFool
Another Bushism Duffy
Marilyn was murdered by the Kennedys btw Rajah
Is anybody else getting sick of Nicolas Cage? Rajah
Fat women ARE mean, disgusting and evil. Mr_Nonsense
Resolved: Fart Jokes Are Inherently Funny. Blackbeard
Anna Nicole Smith dead at 39 Dan_in_Cincinnati
Eating crackers? fellow_consumer
No life firsties! (nl) ModernRonin
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "Norbit " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!