O Brother, Where Art Thou?
Mr. Cranky's rating:
Is there really a point to any Coen brothers film?
Did the Coen brothers actually think that anybody would remember anything that happened in Homer's "The Odyssey" and be able to relate it to this film, which is based on it? For Christ's sake, I don't remember what happened in "All the Pretty Horses" and I saw that last week.As they are wont to do, Joel and Ethan treat this film as an opportunity to take center stage in the circus of the intellectually obtuse. Not only is this based on Homer's classic work, but it's set in the Depression era and is basically a musical. The quest of the film is Ulysses Everett McGill's desire to get back to his wife (Holly Hunter) and stop her from marrying another man. In order to do so, he's got to escape prison. As part of a chain gang, he convinces Pete (John Turturro) and Delmar (Tim Blake Nelson) to go with him, convincing them that he's buried some treasure.
I'm not sure what this means, but the Coens claim to have based this on "The Odyssey" without actually having read it. I guess what they're trying to say --besides "literature sucks" -- is that the film takes classic elements but doesn't synthesize them to the point where the average jackass can't comprehend what's going on. I guess the Coens realized that far more people have read the Cliff Notes to "The Odyssey" than the actual book and, shrewd marketers that they are, made a movie just for them.
Is there really a point to any Coen brothers film? They seem to come up with a couple lines of snappy dialogue and then figure out a way to design an entire film around that. Watching a Coen brothers film is like almost getting into an accident on the freeway. It catches your attention for a moment, but then you forget it ten seconds later.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" forum
Messages:
Public Apology to Jessalyn Leyra Karen_G
Great music and movie John_Holliday
I truly liked this movie Ajoxer
ahh!!!!! devonsawa
O my GOD IT WAS BAD!!!! devonsawa
O Brother, Where Art Thou: My review power_critic
O Cranky, Where art thy taste? (MacDakin)
Expand your vocabularies. (MAYORBOB)
grundle is currently number 2 of Crankyland of master disguises. (Conqueror)
Freaky Friday pulled from elementary school library rack. (MAYORBOB)
A few questions about Crankyland... (whack_chick)
I would guess (Dr_Empirical)
Why do we have to discern? Newbie...Long-time Poster.. Why the prejudice?? (Drew_Atreides)
Your friendly neighborhood Ostrogoth answers... (Theodoric)
A few answers about Crankyland... (MAYORBOB)
A few answers about Crankyland (Slater)
Well, having been here for a year now... (Mad-Ness_Monster)
I see you can't help mentioning me, Slater... (Slothrop)
Yes, Drew..... (Throwing_Muses)
You're doing OK, whack_chick.... (Throwing_Muses)
When, exactly, did this alleged "bitchslapping" take place, Slothrop? (Slater)
Like I said... (Slothrop)
I can answer these. Grizzled Veteran, (Lil_Round_Top)
Yo! W-C! (Coaster)
well...... (grundle)
If you're still here in a year . . . (Slater)
Don't go telling untruths, Slothrop... (skilly)
Do not listen to Throwing Muses whack chick. (Conqueror)
Can you feel the love in this thread? (Chosen_OneX)
You Dumb Bitch. (liquid-sunshine)
There are a few things upon which you may place the utmost trust. (MAYORBOB)
See! (liquid-sunshine)
Re: A few questions about Crankyland... (TheWreck)
Liquid.... (whack_chick)
Drew... (whack_chick)
whack_chick... (skilly)
skilly.... (whack_chick)
Wow - a Slothrop bitchout post... (Homeboy)
No, w_c (Technomage)
hummmmm (mentalcritic)
Seems like no one has mentioned this yet... (Illinois_Stan)
yeah whack chick watch out for grundle and Skilly. (Conqueror)
Protest Rita Rudner style or... (MAYORBOB)
The Ulysses connection was tenuous at best (Minor spoilers if you're picky) (Dr_Empirical)
O Brother, here we go again... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
I came across.... (whack_chick)
Being the mastermind. (Conqueror)
Not quite conqie...... (whack_chick)
worst highschool experience (Toady)
Worst high school experience.. (Drew_Atreides)
Drew (Redundancies)
Please, Drew: (Lil_Round_Top)
Too bad you didn't speak German, Drew... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
My high school years (Junk_Yard_Dog)
French Canadians need to be exterminated (Mr-Mucus)
You sound hot whack chick. This will be my 2nd time I'm going to harass you (Conqueror)
The Worst Part Of High School was... (Wulfgar)
my answer...... (grundle)
grun, ole bun... (Wulfgar)
My worst. (Pawn)
Redo (Drew_Atreides)
Unless that was a joke.. (Drew_Atreides)
Don't know about the worst moment... (Chosen_OneX)
It WAS a joke, Drew. (ShadowEmperor)
Grundle... (whack_chick)
Conqie..... (whack_chick)
High School Wasn't so Bad (Dr_Empirical)
Pawn (Karen_G)
Careful, whack_chick (Jerk-in-the-Box)
High school wasn't so bad... (lurker)
grundle (Pseudonym)
Actually, Pseu (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Karen. (Pawn)
Who can choose just one? (Presley)
Grundle... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
Ha! Presley's pretending he's black again. (Badtz_Maru)
whack_chick (grundle)
I wish I Presley's memory. (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Found in ze personal ads of dhis week's issue of "Libertarian Thinker": Mr. (Happy)
JYD (grundle)
Mr. Happy (grundle)
Oh goody! More historical revisionism from grundle! (Throwing_Muses)
ah, yes, I meant to say... (Pseudonym)
Well, time to make some enemies (Nick-The-Knife)
Nicko, making enemies! (Mr-Mucus)
High School, like life, is what you make of it. (MAYORBOB)
Even if no one else likes Nick (Junk_Yard_Dog)
I never dated in High School either (Critico)
One more thing (Critico)
Wait a second! Nobody likes me?! (Nick-The-Knife)
I like you Nick. (MAYORBOB)
A word of friendly advice for whack_chick (convenor)
What a bunch of pathetic LOSERS! (The_Hate_Guy)
Nick (Presley)
High school was okay. (Violet_Beauregarde)
You aren't fooling anyone Presley (Badtz_Maru)
Clever acronym, Badtz... (Violet_Beauregarde)
Can't you ever say anything in one paragraph? (Nick-The-Knife)
I really hate sob stories. (Veruca_Salt)
Well, Veruca, is there anything you do like? (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Grundle... (jen)
I guess my worst high school memory... (jen)
My high school days (Karen_G)
jen wins (Presley)
Okay... (Nick-The-Knife)
Well, Nick... (Presley)
For everyone in this thread... (whack_chick)
"She earns her paycheck by pretending to be a lot more likable than she is" Your guess is as good as (Lil_Round_Top)
None of the above lil..... (whack_chick)
He wasn't referring to you, whack chick -- that was a quote from my post (Presley)
Ohhh, ok....<nt> (whack_chick)
WROOONG, Presley... (Slothrop)
Before I was kidding, now I'm curious. . . Forgetting about the cat, (Lil_Round_Top)
jen (grundle)
also, jen (grundle)
No, grundle... (jen)
whack_chick (grundle)
jen (grundle)
jen (take notes grundle)... (Slothrop)
Slothrop (grundle)
O Stalker, Where Art Thou? (Jerk-in-the-Box)
Okay, Pres, fair enough (Nick-The-Knife)
The high school question (Hey, remember the point of this discussion?) (EmperorSeth)
You bunch of fucking fags. (Chiz)
My worst high school memory: (NeptuneSalad)
Chiz! (Drew_Atreides)
neptune (llamasex)
I was a high school loser (Boogie_Bass)
NePCH00n (Jerk-in-the-Box)
Sorry, never went to high school. (NeptuneSalad)
Yes, it's quite obvious, isn't it? (Slim_Shady)
:D (NeptuneSalad)
Good one, llamasex! (Theodoric)
Neptune has alot of hidden aggression towards me (llamasex)
Grundle... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
The gheyest site on the net is www.redblack.net (NeptuneSa1ad)
D: (Alabaster)
Grundle.... (whack_chick)
grundle's just pissed... (skilly)
My final answers (Presley)
whack_chick... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
whack_chick (grundle)
Whack Chick, I have a prediction. (MAYORBOB)
well whack chick <G> (miss_enthropic_bitch)
Presley (Technomage)
Also: LOL (NeptuneSalad)
I bought a CD entitled Songbird by Eva Cassidy... (MAYORBOB)
Some schools ban "Cathcer in the Rye" because the main character is white. (grundle)
There needs to be a decent balance of material... (Morrison_Hotel)
Some schools ban "Ulysses" because, well, it's just too fucking hard. (Throwing_Muses)
Toni Morrison? (Pat-The-Bunny)
Damn black folks. (Conqueror)
banning books is stupid. (lurker)
you lying jackass Grundle... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
I never thought this would happen... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
If you think Toni Morrison is easy to read... (Pseudonym)
Having just read "Catcher in the Rye"... (Slothrop)
er, Muses (Edgar_Britt)
Edgar (Shakesmear)
Edgar (Throwing_Muses)
Ringo (grundle)
WOW! (Dr_Empirical)
No, no, no, Dr. E.! (Hairhead)
Hey, Sloth (Chosen_OneX)
Chosen... (Slothrop)
"Our school is 91 percent minority." (Ken_Kaminski)
Weeeeeeeeeeeee! (Chosen_OneX)
Chosen X and Sloth (Pseudonym)
since we're bitching about over-rated literature we read in school... (miss_enthropic_bitch)
Huh... (Wulfgar)
Chosen, Pseu, and Wulfgar... (Slothrop)
Shakesmear and Muses (Edgar_Britt)
Without the intervention of rain.... (Throwing_Muses)
66 runs, two bunnies left (Edgar_Britt)
I can think of something worse than a High School production of... (MAYORBOB)
Well, yeah... most high school productions are painful (Pseudonym)
Edgar (Shakesmear)
I was vastly unimpressed (ShadowEmperor)
I found this interesting... (Mister_Blondie)
Most Happy Person vs. Most Pissed Off Fans (MAYORBOB)
What would the Capalert guy say about the Bible? (grundle)
The Bible (rated PG) (Edgar_Britt)
I wonder if the Capalert guy's even read the Bible... (Morrison_Hotel)
Grundle (Ken_Kaminski)
He didn't reply to you, did he Ken? (Redundancies)
Then why do they bug you people so much (X-MAN)
Also why doesn't Cappy have a right to his beliefs like say gay people (X-MAN)
X-MAN (grundle)
The Bible is GAY (mentalcritic)
I can't believe these words are leaving my mouth but... (speaker4dead)
Except, of course, ex-man ISN'T right (convenor)
grundle (Edgar_Britt)
Re: What would the Capalert guy say about the Bible? (X-MAN)
I decided to check with capalert after seeing Star Trek: Insurrection... (Illinois_Stan)
blegh (mentalcritic)
mentalcritic (grundle)
The fiery pits of HELL AWAIT YOU ALL!!!!! (Thomas_A_Carder)
grundle (Redundancies)
Nice try, Thomas_A_Carder (Kalanaf)
Okay, let's go! (convenor)
You're missing the point, X (Dr_Empirical)
X-turd . . . (Hairhead)
You guys had to bring it up, didn't you? (convenor)
I see Connie has called up the basement libbies (X-MAN)
Damn right, X-MAN (Edgar_Britt)
The offer stands, ex-man (convenor)
Re: What would the Capalert guy say about the Bible? (X-MAN)
there's a bear in there (mentalcritic)
Thanks for that word "brickkiln," mentalcritic (Illinois_Stan)
Note that X was completely unable to respond to my post. (Dr_Empirical)
Okay, you didn't exactly cite anything (convenor)
Grundle... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
rotten (mentalcritic)
No response from the X? What a surprise! (Dr_Empirical)
I asked him (Bob_St_Cul)
Follow The Boys (Coaster)
Oh Brother, Where art thou friggin' ring? (Coaster)
Harvard turns thumbs down on Gore as President. (MAYORBOB)
O Brother, Here I Am (Edgar_Britt)
Er, Mr Cranky... (Edgar_Britt)
"Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" will win the Critical Consensus by a mile (Presley)
Why is this my favorite movie this week? (The_Question)
He's not heavy... (MAYORBOB)
Your brother, Harry Bailey, (Toady)
"Doc, my brother's crazy. (Toady)
My little brother... (Toady)
Fredo, you're my older brother and I love you, (Toady)
You was my brother, Charley, (Toady)
Wally, if your dumb brother tags along, I'm gonna-- (Toady)
And viddy films I would. (Toady)
Brother Poll (Toady)
I respectfully disagree on this one, Mr. C (Karen_G)
Am I first again? (The_Question)
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "O Brother, Where Art Thou? " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!