Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End
Mr. Cranky's rating:
The final battle takes place in a water vortex, a swirling, sucking hole in the middle of the ocean that's neatly analogous to this film's place in American culture.
The second and third movies in this series have scripts that feel like they were written on table napkins by a group of drunken monkeys. My assumption is that the studio was so surprised by the success of the first film that it forced director Gore Verbinski and the rest of the filmmakers to put together a plan for sequels - and fast. I've heard of studios asking for sequel scripts in as little as two weeks. So much for quality and the creative process.
And while I am no less disgusted by this film than the previous pieces of refuse, I have no doubt that this one will also go on to make a billion dollars. We are simply desperate for escapism. The more we lose ourselves in the pirate world -- and this is the only thing "Pirates 3" has going for it -- the more we feel the film has accomplished something. We forget that we're fat or poor or neglected at work or at home and for two hours and forty minutes, we imagine that we are disgusting, dirty, foul-mouthed pirates.
If I endeavor to explain the story in any detail, I'll end up with a review that needs its own ISBN. The plot is one ridiculous detail after another. There's no continuity and it all feels as if it were made up on the spot by a group of scribes whose job it was to imagine individual scenes of monumental expense that could be tacked together to approximate a plot. The final battle takes place in a water vortex, a swirling, sucking hole in the middle of the ocean that's neatly analogous to this film's place in American culture.
Even though Johnny Depp was nominated for an Academy Award, the filmmakers seem actively confused about whom to anoint as their main character. Compared to Depp, Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley seem like wooden puppets. Will Turner (Bloom) searches for his father. Elizabeth Swann (Knightley) proves she can hold her own among men. They're separated then come together. They're on one boat, then another. The plot jumps from Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush) to Captain Sao Feng (Chow Yun-Fat) to the villainous venture between Beckett (Tom Hollander) and Davy Jones (Bill Nighy). Each character that comes on screen introduces another wretched plot point that drives the film further into the realm of discombobulation. The most amusing thing about the film is Barbossa's monkey. Whenever Verbinski needs a "moment," he relies on the monkey. And as if we cared about Sparrow's inner turmoil, Verbinski introduces a ridiculous and wasteful bit of introspection that involves Sparrow talking to other imagined Sparrows.
"Pirates 3" is appallingly long. What Verbinski and crew seem to call entertainment, I call torture.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End" forum
Messages:
Pirates of the Caribbean III DeppLover
this movie sucked!! X-Man
The panda is too stupid to catch its own bamboo. ModernRonin
Has any government agency considered hiring employees RidingFool
x-man really got his ass kicked this week. It's been a good week Ben-Dover-69
Xie jen
So, why are children raised to believe that women are inferior to men? Mal_Content
Wake up and smell the estrogen, folks. Joss Whedon's my new hero. Mal_Content
Cool! My Wildlife Center was on the news... jen
Lasties!!! Coaster
Get a Penis Party bracelet -- http://www.bachelorette.com/bp15270.html Penis_Party
My next door neighbor's a real asshole! Penis_Party
Come join the fun! Penis_Party
Rajah, did you give away your password? The_Little_General
Beef to remain untested, even voluntarily; Libertarians celebrate! convenor
George W. Bush is a total puss Duffy
Al Gore is a big fat weenie X-Man
Rickroll'd X-Man
LOL teh funny pictoore X-Man
Bioshock looks creepy X-Man
Real life TV salaries of TV characters (mildly interesting) X-Man
Bring out yah DEAD!!!! Icky_icky_fetang_zoot
So what's everyone's opinion on Barry Bonds and Hank Aaron's HR record? sonofthedummy
More Dems flee from Fox News Channel debate/ Thompson might run... sonofthedummy
Paris Hilton must check in for 3 weeks of jail soon.. and Nicole Ritchie sonofthedummy
My friend's new puppy has Pravo Dead_Rajah
Let the girls out, dammit! RidingFool
Why did grundle vote for Kerry after he voted for the war? Duffy
They're not tricks, they're *illusions*. Ickyru
Elton John should have died in 1980. Omega_Man
Carl Bernstein & the Clintons Spanky
It's been two years since the "last throes" convenor
Movie Theaters testing a device that pages the manager... sonofthedummy
so the Russians have tested an ICBM that can beat our "Missile Sheild" WHY? sonofthedummy
Need a kidney? You too could get lucky! Prime Mover
Hey, let's play pirates! Barney_the_ Dinosaur
Coaster's oscar buzz builds for worst actress ever X-Man
Was little big girl a terrible crankyland poster? X-Man
reviewer says Kiera Knightly pwns Orlando Bloom in this... sonofthedummy
New google maps craziness. Street view X-Man
Doritoes has a new flavor. X-13D. X-Man
There was a problem with official firsties X-Man
It isn't the media that makes US soldiers hate Iraq, X-dolt Dan_in_Cincinnati
Post credit scene in this movie!!!! 0b1knob
Let's dance! Let's shout! Captain_Lance_Murdoch
China ex-food and drug safety chief sentenced to death Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Me and Mr. Cranky are just alike! Barney_the_ Dinosaur
Lonely? Nobody to talk to? Tired of spamming? Looking for a friend? RidingFool
US to FINALLY impose sanctions on Sudan. sonofthedummy
Nutbag Sheehan calls it quits, blasts Democrat pussies and backstabbers X-Man
So we've been having this fight in the Texas house X-Man
Barney the dinosaur=rajah X-Man
Pirates beats Spiderman 3, sets worldwide opening week BO record 400.1 mil X-Man
Fuck ESPN, it's Alyssa Milano's MLB blog! Throwing_Muses
AAAARRGH! My glasses fell into the toilet Coaster
So, I'm back. Xur
saw the craziest thing on TV just before 10PM... sonofthedummy
Ducks win Stanley Cup game 1? That's unpossible! sonofthedummy
"Build a man a fire, and he will be warm for a day.... Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Coaster & Mal jen
Recently Seen Movies.... MR_MUCUS
Who else has grown tired of Pres 2008 already? sonofthedummy
Transformers teaser... sonofthedummy
Smihsonian censored exhibit on global warming to please the pro-polluters Mr_Happy_Face
Henry Rollins on Wal*Mart sonofthedummy
Charles Nelson Reilly dead Dan_in_Cincinnati
New Chad Vader episodes on You Tube! The_Little_General
Anyone here ever been in a play or studied theater? Terribella
so... a Vietnam vet realtive of mine found out that he was exposed to... sonofthedummy
Saw "Shrek the Third".. Drew_Atreides
A gift given You_People_Are_Silly
Dario Franchitti wins Indy 500, though only because it rained again... sonofthedummy
So why are Hillary and Obama afraid to debate of Faux News? Dan_in_Cincinnati
Maybe it's because they fear the moderator will be Satan himself? sonofthedummy
Democratic leaders shun black caucus debate. They're making a big mistake. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
sonofthedummy, Fox News is letting the black cuacus choose the moderator. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
If the Democrat candidates can't or won't handle FoxNews The_Third_Nipple
I'm not buying any of this from you guys Coaster
Damn, do the dems finally get it?? jwilson07
Coaster's histrionics are so funny You_People_Are_Silly
"afraid" to debate of Faux News? Throwing_Muses
Question is, would Republicans debate at a hostile forum? M_H
before he went to sattelite, the best place to reach "America" was... sonofthedummy
M H Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Some whiny liberal Dems forced Hillary and Obama out of the debate Dan_in_Cincinnati
Dan Coaster
Hannitry and Colmbs is fair and balanced? Coaster
Jay Leno offers the best comment on this topic. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Like Coaster said, H&C isn't really "fair and balanced"... M_H
Coaster some people say John Kerry lost to Bush... Dan_in_Cincinnati
Fox News is simply less left wing than the rest of American news networks X-Man
'Vociferously.' Agrula
M H Captain_Lance_Murdoch
I'm being theoretical... M_H
Well, Agrula ,,, Coaster
'Obama is making the same mistake if he doesn't..........confront?' Prime Mover
^^Well, Coaster, Prime Mover
I love everybody in Crankyland! Barney_the_ Dinosaur
mark steyn tanstaafl
Conqueror slain by 11 year old boy. First pix inside! Throwing_Muses
Lohan DUI coke head car crash genious [sic] Throwing_Muses
Star Wars turned 30 today... sonofthedummy
underdog? Unerdog?? UNDER-Freakin'-DOG????!!!! Coaster
Happy Birthday TMundo! The_Little_General
Bug is going to do crap at the box office You_People_Are_Silly
I think Rajah is behind most of these brand new handles You_People_Are_Silly
The Transformers movie will be bigger than ID4 You_People_Are_Silly
"The Sims" video game optioned to Fox Studios for movie Ickyru
poGeorgia boy kills "hogzilla". Record 1051 und beast X-Man
holy shit! orland bloom left a cabin boy mia_wallace
Sen. Tom Harkin has introduced The Guantanamo Closure Act of 2007 Dan_in_Cincinnati
Hasselback beat the crap out of Rosie huh? X-Man
Scotland to become an independent nation? Dan_in_Cincinnati
Rodger "Batman" Clemens still not ready for primetime... sonofthedummy
War funding fight delayed to September... sonofthedummy
Olsen twin in "Weeds" Spanky
Here ya go, boys and girls. There's still time to make it. RidingFool
Aaaaarrrrgggghhhh Mateys! Blackbeard
Canada is making a shitload of money selling oil to USA right now X-Man
Oooh nat looks so good! X-Man
There's a missile defense test today X-Man
Democrats bitch to death and die over Iraq X-Man
I seen the other chick on "Lizzie MCGuire" has a movie now X-Man
Firsties! X-Man
Support banning oil use in Canada X-Man
This is gonna own Spidey 3 at the B.O. X-Man
Is Vanessa Branch, lovely spokesperson for Orbit gum, in this movie? 0b1knob
Hmm, give Bush what he wants and he suddenly concedes much much more! sonofthedummy
"24" Movie not happening until at least 2010... sonofthedummy
The "Pirates" franchise held such promise Aron
Summer of Love - 40 year reunion RidingFool
Keith Richards "cameo" is blatantly obvious... sonofthedummy
Mr Cranky must apologize to drunken monkeys... sonofthedummy
You know the world is screwed when... sonofthedummy
Are you crying Rep. Boener?! There's no crying in Congress!! sonofthedummy
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
Do you ever have the feeling dogmeat
Anyone game for a music poll? Terribella
While 'Pirates' no doubt racks up the bucks Shakesmear
So what's your point this time, nerd? Terribella
Hey, is Trey Parker Canadian or Coloradan? Terribella
I don't know why the people in Iraq can't play nice and share! Barney_the_ Dinosaur
Actually, it's Saskassippi and Winterpeg, RidingFool
Ummmm, so troops have to die while hydrogen is more efficient than oil? TMundo
Hydrogen is not more efficient than oil X-Man
Tech doesn't exist to make hydrogen the ideal replacement yet. MR_MUCUS
Yes, that drives me nuts in the whole 'hydrogen' debate. Xur
I think you can run a car on love alone! Barney_the_ Dinosaur
Aluminum plants don't grow just anywhere. RidingFool
One thing not cosidered thus far by you guyz: Miles/Tank Coaster
water vapor = #1 greenhouse gas You_People_Are_Silly
yes, wikipedia. The source of all "truth" on the internet friend_request_denied
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ice/greenhouse.html You_People_Are_Silly
frd/Coaster owned big time, btw You_People_Are_Silly
Wop whore vapor? MR_MUCUS
It is misleading to cite the role of water vapor as a greenhouse gas Coaster
Um, no, Coaster You_People_Are_Silly
Hydrogen cars = more water vapor = more of #1 greenhouse gas You_People_Are_Silly
Coaster is trying to skirt the issue, btw You_People_Are_Silly
How much can we trust Michael Mann? MR_MUCUS
Hmmm....that last You Pee post sounded Grundle-ish. MR_MUCUS
Thanks, Muc, but allow me to help our friend out here Coaster
&^%%$$#@!!, I meant to type "COASTER FLOODS NEW ORLEANS" Coaster
ATTENTION T MUNDO jwilson07
um, no You_People_Are_Silly
GEEZ!! Let me put this in terms even YOU can understand!!! Coaster
You Pee is kinda retarded Ben-Dover-69
No, actually I'm one of the few really smart posters You_People_Are_Silly
You hide it well The_Little_General
LOL!!!1 Ben-Dover-69
Terribella Shakesmear
PS Shakesmear
Realistically the most troublingsource of greenhouse gas is Coasters farts X-Man
Then I would suggest next time The_Little_General
In regards to globaling warming, I have a confession... MR_MUCUS
Well, Muuc Coaster
Damn. Xur
AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. Zion
Firsties Bitches! Coda
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!