Shall We Dance
Mr. Cranky's rating:
Apparently, making a few hundred thousand dollars a year, looking like Richard Gere, and having Susan Sarandon as your wife leaves a quarry-sized hole in your heart and only ballroom dancing can fill it.
For those who don't know, this is an Americanized remake of a 1996 Japanese film, which means that it took Hollywood an astonishing eight years to figure out how to rip the heart out of a small and generally insignificant film. Normally, Hollywood can rip the heart out of something in just a few seconds by hiring a few incompetent writers and casting David Spade.
The original was about a Japanese accountant who discovers an escape from his predictable existence by learning the fine art of ballroom dancing. The remake is about John Clark (Richard Gere) and his wife, Beverly (Susan Sarandon). He's a lawyer and she's a fashion executive. They live in a very swank Chicago suburb. Instead of driving his car into town (or being chauffeured, given how much money he and his wife probably make), he rides the El. The reason he rides the El is so that he can see Paulina (Jennifer Lopez) staring pensively from the window of Miss Mitzi's dance studio.
Apparently, making a few hundred thousand dollars a year, looking like Richard Gere, and having Susan Sarandon as your wife leaves a quarry-sized hole in your heart and only ballroom dancing can fill it. See, this is precisely what Hollywood doesn't understand about the concept of heart-warming stories. When you populate plots with Hollywood royalty, the story takes on less relevance than Mary-Kate Olson at a Weight Watchers convention. It's called an "everyman" for a reason. The audience is more likely to identify with a space alien than with Richard Gere.
Further gutting this story's soul is a supporting cast that rivals the freak show at a circus. Quickly, the film becomes less of a contest of ballroom dancing and more of an experiment to see how many B-list actors can be quirky enough to get a shot at a best supporting actor nomination. Stanley Tucci's lawyer character wears a wig and heavy make-up while dancing. Chic (Bobby Cannavale), a fellow beginning dancer, talks about how many women he's going to bed with his new skill (a sure sign he's gay). Bobbie (Lisa Ann Walter) is a loud-mouthed, somewhat experienced dancer who is desperate for attention. John is just trying to find himself.
During this movie, I wanted to find myself too… outside the theater.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Shall We Dance" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "Shall We Dance" forum
Messages:
It's Thursday night in the forums! Whee! Xur
John Doe will be LIVE at Boreal Ski resort in Tahoe, California. John_Doe
Jiggly JIG JIG Jiggly puff PUFF puff JIGGLY PUFF!!! Jigglypuff
Aron, Be Careful. Coaster
MR HAPPY FACE CANT READ! X-Man
Cinderella story came out! X-Man
Bush and Kerry are cousins? Aron
GO ASTROS!!! Mazzy
Grundle's favorite environmentalist in the news again SavageWombat
Oh, and another thing... morganlefey
Ok, my prediction was wrong...but the Sox did win..... morganlefey
You Rang? Rajah
Battleground state of Pennsylvania wrestling over election monitoring teams Theodoric
BEWARE THE WOODCHUCK! Rajah
Issue Of The Week church
If the Red Sox don't win this ALCS... Aron
I saw the most beautiful girl on TV last night. X-Man
If you must go to hospital, don't go to Poland. church
What we be so great about looking like Richard Gere, anyway? Theodoric
What's wrong with this picture? church
Meh. Xur
I'd like to dedicate this one to the upcoming election Theodoric
Pat Robertson says Bush told him there would be no casualties in Iraq Mr_Happy_Face
A quote from Winston Churchill that summarizes this political season. jazzdrive_for_me
A chick-tastic thread just for Aron, chock full of kiddies and catfights. Becky_Sharp
Ratings for "reality shows" are down this season morganlefey
New Orleans Aron
C'MON, EVERYBODY! Let's SING ALONG!!!!!!! MAYOBOB
check it mojo
Eww. Bush actually kisses babies. Becky_Sharp
Bikerfox mojo
Safe sex means setting the parking brake, people convenor
How 'bout those Red Sox mangy-ranger
BIKERFOX is in the house!!!!!!! mojo
Total military victory in Iraq is only days away Mr_Happy_Face
There are approximately 800 posts on this page Aron
Go ahead and hate your neighbor! Rajah
Hmm, I wonder if John Howard knows this guy... Theodoric
Stop the Republi-C-U-N-T thieves. X-MAN_SUCKS_COCK
Topsies. X-MAN_SUCKS_COCK
Topsies X-Man
Mr Cranky or Hans please ban X-MAN. X-MAN_SUCKS_COCK
Mr Cranky or Hans please ban X-MAN. Nick-The-Bitch
IP ban James Duck Dodgers IV X-Man
Please stop spamming the forums X-man James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Please stop spamming the forums X-man. James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Please stop spamming the forums X-man.. James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Please stop spamming the forums X-man. James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Please stop spamming the forums X-man James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
20+ spam threads in the last 30 minutes from X-man James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
It's time to move to another forum. church
Mr Cranky, someone is spamming your board X-Man
DJ JOHN DOE WILL BE SPINNING AT ANU BAR ON WEDNESDAY NIGHT. wiIbert
Why does X-man support the GOP? James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Why does X-man oppose democracy? wiIbert
Why does X-man support fascism? James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Why does X-man oppose democracy? James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Shocking video of girlie man X-Man brushing hair wiIbert
Remember the good old days? X-Man
Why does X-man hate America so much? James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
Cheney's obviously been snorting coke off Laura Bush's stomach again. wiIbert
Defeat George Bush wiIbert
X-MAN SUPPORTS UN MILITARY ACTION AGAINST REPUBLICAN ELECTION FRAUD. wiIbert
Is military force neccesary to stop Bush & thugs from rigging elections? wiIbert
Libertarians for Kerry Rajah
Stop the RepubliCON thieves wiIbert
Is X-Man a Democrat? wiIbert
Isn't this movie like, old? X-Man
Is military force necessary to stop Democrat cheating in Florida? X-Man
Stop the Democrap election thieves X-Man
Defeat John Kerry <nt> X-Man
Shocking video of girlie man Edwards brushing hair X-Man
Kerry planning to lie, cheat, fraud elections X-Man
Stop the Democrat election stealing X-Man
Are the cheating Democraps already attempting to steal Florida elections? X-Man
Viagra for women? church
Anybody read Kobe Abe's 'Woman In The Dunes'? Throwing_Muses
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
DJ JOHN DOE WILL BE SPINNING AT ANU BAR ON WEDNESDAY NIGHT. John_Doe
New York city smells bottled and sold as perfume. Throwing_Muses
JIGGLY JIG JIG JIGG!!! JIG JIGG JIGGLYPUFF PUFF PUFF!!!! Jigglypuff
Crankylanders WILL EMBRACE STAR WARS AS THEIR PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE CONQUERER
Drew Critico
Jesus God, Coaster... skilly
Have you heard about this W ketchup? Xur
Cheney says terrorists may bomb U.S. cities! convenor
Massachusetts was just rated the most intellegent state in the US... morganlefey
Bush on Evolution Rajah
Is Dick Cheney conclusive proof that Satan exists? Rajah
Question about girlfriends and drugs Drew_Atreides
Sounds like you got a keeper there! Rajah
Not meaning to be too harsh, but... Mr_Happy_Face
Drew Coaster
i agree with Coaster Critico
agree... lose that and walk on... Grover
It is an amazing world you people live in. gnosticdogma
Interesting. Jerk-in-the-Box
So, gnosticdogma, what would you do? Coaster
In the cast, Coaster, it's obvious what Drew's problem is Ken_Kaminski
Which, by the way Ken_Kaminski
Drew Anita_Bonghit
well....... grundle
What's the big deal about being on the nod in a Wal-Mart parking lot? skilly
What I would have done. gnosticdogma
Drew, what you should do with her . . . Hairhead
What's wrong with sleeping with strange guys? skilly
There are eight bazillion fish in The Sea Of Love mangy-ranger
I agree with mangy Ken_Kaminski
Yeah, they aren't much to look at... mangy-ranger
I agree... Slothrop
See, the part that really concerns me is the two guys Drew_Atreides
Oh forgot to say "thanks" Drew_Atreides
Perhaps, Drew . . . Hairhead
There doesn't seem to be anything wrong Drew. John_Doe
Yeah, Hairhead Drew_Atreides
Drew, you need to act now, whilst she's still repentant. Throwing_Muses
Show her that you care and support her... skilly
And then... church
Haha, skilly Drew_Atreides
You never noticed the smell on her before? MR_MUCUS
I bought stuff at Wal-Mart today, btw MR_MUCUS
The problem isn't the drugs it's sex. X-Man
Naw.. Drew_Atreides
Good work, soldier. Throwing_Muses
well...... grundle
God, if only that were true. gnosticdogma
Hit girl wit frying pan Mr_Nonsense
The problem isn't sex, it's X-Man. X-MAN_SUCKS_COCK
CREEPY POST GRUNDLE X-Man
X-Man grundle
Confidential to Drew... Dingo_8_My_Baby
Drew Critico
"...now she looks like a heroin addict." skilly
"Her boyfriend with the $3,000 spinning hubcaps is black." Jerk-in-the-Box
It's been obvious she's been using drugs for weeks at least MR_MUCUS
<adds an "s" to Muke's word> Theodoric
confidential to Gnosticdogma... Dingo_8_My_Baby
Wrong, Theo MR_MUCUS
Ohio man fills out 100+ fraudulent voter registration forms for crack. Theodoric
Crankyland Football League Weekly Final Results The_Innocent_Bystander
New Superman possibly cast... M_H
Necormania: The long lost Ed Wood porn film on DVD. JaneTheeIgnorantSlut
Number one is to find some friends and say church
Reading your mind church
BOARD RIOT BOARD RIOT BOARD RIOT (My password is cranky!) PROTESTER
10 Differences between John Doe the Ho (As an enemy) and me. wiIbert
Don't you people ever sleep?? XEROX_BOY
John Doe. Mr_Mucus
AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. James_Duck_Dodgers_IV
CBS: SBGI DROPS ON ADVERTISING CONCERNS Bort
Totally Cool! Star Trek MMORPG is being created!!! John_Doe
Hey, your car stereo is state of the art Xur
Another Classic J Lo Remake Mikurtis
Is "stagflation" around the corner? this could be very bad, sez Theodoric
Florida begins to vote, fuck ups under way. Throwing_Muses
Revisiting conclusions: Return of the King & Kill Bill v.2 (spoilers) M_H
Bush seperate from the "reality-based community"... M_H
Riot Possibility? mojo
Contents of The Looney Tunes Golden Collection Volume 2 grundle
Totally Cool! Star Trek MMORPG is being created!!! X-g-M
Unbelievable. Bush widening gap in polls Mr_Happy_Face
Army resorting to desperation measures to avoid draft rumors convenor
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
Was Liberace really gay? clueless Rajah
tap on my window church
UN Commander in Haiti blames Kerry for violence there Theodoric
Utah sheriff to document any porn found at crime scenes Theodoric
This is a Colonel Korn Special church
This is... strange. church
Coaster Public Service Announcement Coaster
I wonder if Kerry might lose the popular vote, but win the election? Theodoric
Totally Cool! Star Trek MMORPG is being created!!! Jerk-in-the-Box
Rumour has it that Half Life 2 has gone gold. Darth-Shithead
Kerry is acting like a Republican. grundle
Totally Cool! Star Trek MMORPG is being created!!! John_Doe
John O'neil pilots his swift boat onto the shoal of facts Coaster
Kerry has voted to raise taxes 100 times! Rajah
Australian woman sleepwalks and has sleepsex with strange men. Theodoric
Fans celebrate 30th anniversary of Dungeons and Dragons Theodoric
Game Day - Week 6 The_Innocent_Bystander
Bush Campaign exudes Stench of Death . . . Hairhead
I almost feel sorry for the Red Sox at this point. Almost. Darth-Shithead
Saw "Tarnation" . . . . Dingo_8_My_Baby
The left hates Mary Cheney Spanky
How is it an all volunteer army.... Rajah
Finally saw "Before Sunrise" Xur
AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. Jerk-in-the-Box
Shall We Dance with Mike Moore? The_Innocent_Bystander
JOHN DOE: MAN-WHORE OF THE MOUNTIES Mr_Mucus
Vote for your 20 favorite movies at Your Movie Database. grundle
Rajah the best to you each morning Rajah
Chloe don't know better Theodoric
Anyone catch Jon Stewart on "Crossfire" today? M_H
Bush fiscal incompetence - Repubbies want your pension! Throwing_Muses
Bush to Reinstate the Draft Coaster
Richard Gere and the gerbil Rajah
JOHN DOE: MAN-WHORE OF THE MOUNTIES X-g-M
Boo! pantslessness
AWESOME!!! Star Trek: Conquest OPEN BETA available to download. The_Return_of_ Darker_Conqueror
Liar Bush is making the same promises that he made and broke 4 years ago. grundle
Hey, who lives in San Francisco and has nothing to do tonight? Eamon
GREAT. One more thing Germany will SCREW UP Nuke_Mecca
Science finally catches up with Aron. Xur
Where's all the good movies? X-Man
Kerry lied about women making 76 cents on the dollar. grundle
(Sigh) grundle, why do you bother posting all this shit? Eamon
To annoy you, of course. Why else would I post it? grundle
For every $1 a WOMAN WHORE makes, a MAN WHORE makes .50 cents. John_Doe
Grundle admits it! SavageWombat
Just Proves that Kerry's a . . . Nuke_Mecca
So the pot says to the kettle... ModernRonin
SavageWombat grundle
Gee, Mr. Pot..... Nuke_Mecca
Interesting observation. ModernRonin
Gee, maybe if Gore had won his own state... Nuke_Mecca
No such thing as a private post on a public messageboard. Jerk-in-the-Box
business owners aren't just greedy, they're also sexist Hazel-Rah
need to contain my enthusiasm for that "post article" button Hazel-Rah
Hazel-Rah grundle
grundle Hazel-Rah
Hazel grundle
You'd like me to shut up about that, wouldn't you? ModernRonin
As for your other points... ModernRonin
maternity leave Hazel-Rah
Hazel grundle
FMLA (Family Medical Leave Act) is actually unpaid leave Theodoric
Btw2, in practical terms, FMLA.... Theodoric
Yeah, well...... grundle
As far as I'm concerned... PAWA
Theo knows about FMLA X-Man
It's unpaid? X-Man
X-Man wouldn't care since he's a cheap man-hooker. Jerk-in-the-Box
X-Man Theodoric
The FMLA requirements Theodoric
It's official. Kerry wants price controls on prescription drugs. grundle
JOHN DOE GOES CRAZY IN CLASSROOM (ARTICLE) John_Doe
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
I can honestly say, I DEFINITELY identify with Richard Gere Cajunman
That Burger King ad on tv Rajah
Adios Aron
Seriously, these fucking talking ads need to stop. Eamon
Don't you people ever sleep?? Xur
Anyone see the original Shall We Dance? Ickyru
Shall We Save The Last Dance? Theodoric
Unbelievably, this film was made in Winnipeg. WINNIPEG!!! Darth-Shithead
Firsties. Darth-Shithead
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "Shall We Dance " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!