Snow Falling on Cedars

Bomb Rating: 

This movie makes you want to slap grown-up reporter Ishmael Chambers (Ethan Hawke) in the face and tell him to just get over it. When he was just a lad, maybe like twelve, he fell in love with a beautiful Japanese girl named Hatsue (Youki Kudoh). Now, all grown up, Ishmael reflects on his obsession with Hatsue as the now-married woman faces the horror of seeing her husband, Kazuo (Rick Yune), tried for the murder of another fisherman in the fictional town of San Pedro, just north of Puget Sound.

This all takes place in 1950, so there's still a lot of animosity toward Japanese-Americans, threatening the chances of a just verdict. So while this trial is going on, Ishmael sits up in the balcony recalling when he and Hatsue hid in the trunk of a tree and kissed for the first time. After Ishmael's marriage proposal is rejected by Hatsue, he goes off to war and loses his arm. In case you aren't yet fully dialed in to Ishmael's problems, he calls Hatsue a bitch just before the doctors chop the thing off.

Perhaps I was so inundated by director Scott ("Shine") Hicks' use of dramatic music that I missed it, but I certainly didn't notice Ishmael missing an arm. Suddenly, there he is, and no arm. Of course, having a sappy film score rammed down one's throat is usually enough to make one's eyes cross and lose focus, but I could have sworn they forgot to CGI that arm out of there and it was just something thrown in at the last minute in the interest of drama.

Much of the story is "internalized," which is filmspeak for "slow, boring, and not much happens." All we really get is the trial and lots of flashbacks of Ishmael and Hatsue necking in this hollowed out tree trunk. Basically, Ishmael eventually figures out how to act like a decent human being despite his resentment, which is a subject far more worthy of a short self-help book than a long-ass two-and-a-half hour film.

To spread the word about this Snow Falling on Cedars review on Twitter.

To get instant updates of Mr. Cranky reviews, subscribe to our RSS feed.

Like This Snow Falling on Cedars Review? Vote it Up.


Rate This Movie:

Other Cranky Content You Might Enjoy

  • Yo, dog. When I think about a white actor capable of hanging out and interacting with the gang bangers in South Central, I naturally think of Ethan Hawke.

  • This is Joe Pesci at his weaseliest, in a role which won him an Oscar ("Most Weasely"),endeared him to the American public and cleared the way for him to play weasels in other films such as "Casino,"

  • Ever since "The Blair Witch Project," every asshole with access to a digital camera has been trying to think up compelling, cheap ways to make another horror movie with a ridiculously simple concept.