bleah





Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith (guest review)


Mr. Cranky's rating:
4 Bombs


Becky_Sharp writes: "Lucas, Spielberg and their ilk have "tinkered" with their earlier films before. Clearly, they value regular infusions of cash over respect for history, continuity, and the integrity of their work, so it seems prequels are inevitable."



I recently returned a day early from a trip and found my husband on the couch, dallying with a piece of white trash he picked up at the library. It was "Star Wars: Episode III, Revenge of the Sith." Why white trash? Let me count the ways:

-Dialogue alternately stolen from Dr. Phil and the Lifetime Network? That's pretty white.

-Jive-talking alien Jar-Jar Binks? Gettin' whiter.

-A Samuel L. Jackson so mellow and non-threatening I began to suspect chemical castration? Oh, you better believe that's white, motherfucker!

There was so much in this movie to abhor. Don't get me wrong; watching a spry little Yoda fling himself at people's throats like Monty Python's Killer Rabbit was quality entertainment, but having to sit through 90 minutes of incoherent xenophobic geek-crack to get there seems like a poor trade.

However, more than Lucas' laughably one-note approach, what bothers me about this movie is that it presumes to change my view of history. If Lucas wanted to pull a Spielberg and bring a doddering Harrison Ford out of retirement, out of Calista Flockhart, or wherever he happened to be and do a crappy fourth "Star Wars," I would be okay with that. But making subsequent films "prequels" to the narrative forces the viewer to see the original movies through an inferior lens. (Side rant: I'm a child of the 70's, so you would think I'd be used to having my childhood strip-mined for every cartoon, movie, and toy I once held dear. But even after two "Scooby-Doo" movies and a "Transformers", it still upsets me.)

Lucas, Spielberg and their ilk have "tinkered" with their earlier films before. Clearly, they value regular infusions of cash over respect for history, continuity, and the integrity of their work, so it seems prequels are inevitable. But every cloud has a silver lining. Anyone want to read my screenplay for "Indiana Jones and the Placenta of Peril?"

--Becky_Sharp

Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith (guest review)" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!



  • Post a New Message in the "Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith (guest review)" forum

  • Messages:

    If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.



    Mr. Cranky's Archives Mr. Cranky's Home Page




  • Search Mr. Cranky:


    Search the "Internets":
    Google



    Shopping with Mr. Cranky!
    Earn us operating funds
    with every purchase
    begun from these links!

    Get your "Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith (guest review)" stuff here!
    We earn 5% on every purchase!

    DVD
    VHS
    Soundtrack
    Book
    Poster

    Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:

    5% on all purchases! amazon.com
    25% on all purchases! allposters.com
    5-10% on all purchases! Gorilla Nation Studio Store
    $9 for new sign-ups!




    Mr. Cranky Gear
    Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!





    Rescue Samoyeds -- Found a Samoyed? 
Want to adopt a Samoyed? It's Samoyed Rescue Alliance (SRA) to the rescue! NFL football game lines: Set the Line on NFL football games!Rescue Samoyeds -- Found a Samoyed? Want to adopt a Samoyed? It's Samoyed Rescue Alliance (SRA) to the rescue! Flaregun: An impolite publication of livid centrists dedicated to the battle for a beter America Bug Bash: 
A comic strip about technology Hans Bjordahl: Comics, columns and general troublemaking