The Talented Mr. Ripley
Mr. Cranky's rating:
Mr. Ripley's main talent is being an imbecile.
This entire film is seen through the eyes of Tom Ripley (Matt Damon), a murderer, and the real question is not whether Tom will get away with his murders but whether he will find happiness. This is because Ripley is the film's protagonist, and we are sympathetic to his needs and desires. We have no choice. Director Anthony ("The English Patient") Minghella has theoretically put us in the position of wanting to see Tom succeed.Except that I couldn't have cared less about anything in this film. The first object of Tom's desire is Dickie Greenleaf (Jude Law), an American loafing around in Italy with his girlfriend, Marge Sherwood (Gwyneth Paltrow). In other words, Dickie is loaded. His father (James Rebhorn) explains to Tom that what Dickie is really good at is spending his allowance. He pays Tom a thousand dollars to go to Italy and convince Dickie to come home. God forbid he should cut off Dickie's allowance and just force him to come home. Instead, he hires some stranger to go find him.
It's no revelation that Tom ends up killing Dickie, because really, what else is he going to do? Tom is gay. Dickie is straight. And nobody, but nobody in the world wants to see a gay relationship where one of the male participants' names is Dickie. So Tom just ends up killing him, which is no great loss to the world, really. Tom, from the lower class, kills Dickie, from the upper class. Marx would have been proud. Victory for the worker!
Who knows how long Tom could have traipsed around Europe, but he's after Dickie's life and he stays in Italy, which leads to all kinds of problems. There's Marge, who starts to suspect something is up when Dickie doesn't come around anymore. There's Freddie Miles (Philip Seymour Hoffman), who suspects Tom immediately. And there's Meredith (Cate Blanchett), who believes Tom is Dickie. Do we care when things don't work out for anybody? Not really. Minghella certainly has done a fine job of making his film convince us that Mr. Ripley's main talent is being an imbecile.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "The Talented Mr. Ripley" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "The Talented Mr. Ripley" forum
Messages:
Confusing Lemon_boat
damon's a kewl actor boy
Movie forum or free-for-all? Guinevere17
A review from someone who actually paid attention. Morgen
THIS JUST SUMS IT ALL UP hellopeople
WHOM AMONGST US WEAR LIKE MASKS? (Ripley_2001)
The only reason (Aurora)
Are there any movies you DO like, Mr. Cranky - or have I missed the point s (Rock_Bottom)
the book was better always mess up the book@aol.com (curly)
Another overhyped disaster (yuck)
warning (none1)
Two word review (Concupiscent_Necktie)
Explanation required (Pat-The-Bunny)
Jude Law's Ass (RedPanda)
I was scared to go to the bathroom (bellaluna)
this lousy movie.... (the_majordomo)
But the actor who plays him isn't (ElMonteSlim)
The Talented? Mr Ripley (findbelle)
YUCK! (cornvict)
Back again (The_Hate_Guy)
Madonna to salute American Music at the Superbowl (Throwing_Muses)
My Review of THE TALENTED MR. RIPLEY (Beast)
Wondering if I've made any impact... (LAJay)
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls of Crankyland..... (LightyearWanBurton)
Just listened to the "magnolia" CD... (Scorsese_fan)
Not much going on here (Nicky)
My review of THE TALENTED MR. RIPLEY... (Beast)
Happy Birthday To... (Tralala)
When my dad and I saw this movie... (SPOILERS) (speaker4dead)
I don't want to make a big deal out of this, but (Veruca_Salt)
! (neighborhood_of_infinity)
ANNOUNCEMENT! CRANKY PICS! (jen)
Interesting to see who submits them (Edgar_Britt)
i can't wait (mia_wallace)
BOLO... (mendo)
BTW, jenny... (mendo)
Mendo... (jen)
hey, jenny... it wasn't a complaint... (mendo)
AAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (Chica)
Are you seeing things I'm not?? (the_celluloid_prophet)
TCP... and Chica (mendo)
HEY....who got Mr. Cranky to join in the reindeer games? (TheGodmother)
Seriously...is that Mr C???? (Throwing_Muses)
mendo (Junk_Yard_Dog)
TCP (Junk_Yard_Dog)
G-Mom (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Throwing Muses (Junk_Yard_Dog)
No more "hiding" behind handles..... (TheGodmother)
jen, let me be the first to say that this was a VERY BAD IDEA (CreepFreakLoser)
thinks discord is kinda cute. (mia_wallace)
CFL (Technomage)
but then again, that might be a bad thing (mia_wallace)
Re (X-MAN)
Postscript (X-MAN)
Oh, Creep!! (Throwing_Muses)
i kinda liked those cranky cum shots, myself (mia_wallace)
WOW (the_celluloid_prophet)
Finally! (Veruca_Salt)
Hmmmmm... (Poor_College_Boy)
CFL... (jen)
Damn I wish i had some pics of myself (Nicky)
Jen, my friend (sweaty-twat)
Who would have ever thought Discord would be such a babe?! (IrvingPThorneIII)
Somehow, I feel redeemed. (skilly)
skilly... (Ringo_ate_my_baby)
Ringo... (skilly)
Skilly, you are drop-dead gorgeous... (IrvingPThorneIII)
Mendo's a babe, too. I think the biggest surprise to me was Ms. Phan. (IrvingPThorneIII)
No offense, but I imagined skilly hotter... (Badtz_Maru)
THAT'S Mr.Cranky!!!!! (Alpan)
Hmmm...skilly... (Wulfgar)
Hmm... (Amok)
Damn, this sucks. (xyz)
Where are all of these pics at? (season)
Honey, haven't you been paying attention? (IrvingPThorneIII)
My bad, Irving! (season)
Now wait just one bloody moment (Philm_Phan)
Okay, now I have seen everyone (season)
I'm so vain. (Fierce_Molly)
Decisions, decisions... (skilly)
On first glance (Veruca_Salt)
Re: ANNOUNCEMENT! CRANKY PICS! (season)
Re: ANNOUNCEMENT! CRANKY PICS!..forget that last post (season)
It's okay, season (Scorsese_fan)
*Whew* (season)
season (Junk_Yard_Dog)
JYD (season)
OMG.....skilly has a doppelganger!!!! (Throwing_Muses)
Whoops! jen.... (TheGodmother)
Gmom (jen)
Folks....updated pages! (jen)
So THAT'S what skilly's face looks like! (Nick-The-Knife)
I have to give Sailor Uranus/Phonebooth credit (CreepFreakLoser)
*Ahem* (the_celluloid_prophet)
TCP... tom_boy is.... (mendo)
mendo (the_celluloid_prophet)
More. (gnosticdogma)
I'm with you, gnostic! (skilly)
BTW, Gdog... (jen)
I suppose I have faded from memory somewhat... (Death)
Hi all (Rochelle)
And... (Rochelle)
Re: ANNOUNCEMENT! CRANKY PICS! (Junk_Yard_Dog)
I'm confused, JYD... (skilly)
skilly (Junk_Yard_Dog)
*glortble*ack*cough (Death)
JYD (_Elizabeth_)
Interesting pics...shall I send mine? (FerretBoy)
I knew FB loved me (Junk_Yard_Dog)
Holy Smoke! - Kate Winslet in full frontal nudity!!! (spoilers) (Throwing_Muses)
Favorite directors/actors/actresses poll (Scorsese_fan)
"Gwynnie"'s next movie (Veruca_Salt)
gnosticdogma/Discord Dialogues #29: "Play" (gnosticdogma)
sniffing something sweet? (sweaty-twat)
AAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!! (Alpan)
Has anyone here ever had laser surgery to correct their vision? (IrvingPThorneIII)
What happened to Richard B Bernstein? (season)
He left after some doo-dah in the basement. (IrvingPThorneIII)
Re: What happened to Richard B Bernstein? (season)
Re: What happened to Richard B Bernstein? Rant 'N' Rave (Wulfgar)
A big scuffle or fight. It may have been with DS, but I'm not sure (nt) (IrvingPThorneIII)
Thanks, Wulfgar... (IrvingPThorneIII)
Irv... Rant 'N' Rave (Wulfgar)
Irving you big dick having hunk (sweaty-twat)
Uhhh... Rant 'N' Rave (Wulfgar)
wulfy mr. sugary dick (sweaty-twat)
Season (sweaty-twat)
You know, good erotica has its place in the world... (IrvingPThorneIII)
Irving spank me i've been a bad little whore (sweaty-twat)
skanky, std infested moron... (season)
yeesh... (Wulfgar010)
This site (Nicky)
Re: What happened to Richard B Bernstein? (season)
I saw RBB last night on ESPN2 (Fat_Ed)
Hey'you know if all of the elders keep leaving and (white-heat)
Richard (Roy_Foltrigg)
Ack (Roy_Foltrigg)
Good recap, Roy (convenor)
Right. (gnosticdogma)
Convenor (Roy_Foltrigg)
And, with that... (skilly)
Yay! Now I'm a member of the "Lurking Richard Threatening Email Club!" (skilly)
Hey Fat ed! (X-MAN)
Richard's good... (Poor_College_Boy)
What happened to Richard B. Bernstein? Richard_ (B_Bernstein)
Richard B Bernstein: (NeptuneSalad)
That was the poorest excuse .... Ghost of (Corthas)
You got that right, PCB... Wulfgar Is (Wulfgar)
My apologies, Corthas... Wulfgar Is A Dumb (Wulfgar)
Re: What happened to Richard B Bernstein? (season)
He left because of trolls!? Two Women Escaping in a (Phonebooth)
It wasn't quite that simple (convenor)
Two women.. (season)
Ladies... (Wulfgar)
Well... (Eamon_J_Doyle)
Eamon (season)
Re: What happened to Richard B Bernstein? (season)
season (Roy_Foltrigg)
haiku (ZenMaster)
haiku... (mendo)
Well, goddam YOU, Richard (Nick-The-Knife)
Nick (Roy_Foltrigg)
haiku (ZenMaster)
now, here's something (mia_wallace)
Who else is seeing "Magnolia" this weekend? (Scorsese_fan)
Beck's "Mutations" (Scorsese_fan)
DEEZ NUTS IS.... (HeavyBalls2)
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "The Talented Mr. Ripley " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!