The Thing

Bomb Rating: 

Mr. Cranky hates remakes, but Mr. Cranky hates it even more when cult films get recast as big-budget flicks that strip any vestige of what might have been cool out of the original and then set it on fire in front of you so you can watch your childhood memories burn alongside the $15 you paid to get into the theatre. This is exactly what happened when they decided to shit all over John Carpenter's grave and put out a new version of the horror classic "The Thing."

Ok, so Carpenter isn't dead yet, but I'm sure if he attended a screening of the new "The Thing" he would immediately slit his own wrists and bury them deep in the corn popper outside in the lobby. I mean, that's what I almost did and I had no part in bringing his original masterpiece to life in 1982.

No one liked Carpenter's version of "The Thing" when it originally came out because everyone was ooing and ahhing over fucking "E.T." which offered a kinder, gentler kind of alien that didn't fucking rip your face off, assume your identity and kill all of your friends. No one likes the remake of "The Thing" because it sucks harder than Bea Arthur taking a bong hit at Jimmy Carter's ranch.

Where to start? How about we ignore that joke about a president no one remembers and instead focus on the fact that genius director Matthijs van Heijningen decided to punish the world for the fact that it took him until the 4th grade to learn his name by removing any and all traces of the mystery from the concept of "The Thing," making it a straight-ahead, by-the-numbers horror flick. Imagine if they remade "Jaws" and instead of being a stealthy killer the shark was instead actually driving the boat and on-camera for 90 percent of the film having a few beers with Quint and crew. That's the kind of ham-fisted storytelling audiences are treated to in "The Thing."

The entire situation is made even worse by the fact that the movie has no characters. Oh, there are humans populating the Antarctic research station where what I am hesitant to refer to as a "story" unfolds, but they have all of the depth of the teenage girl you took to senior prom when you were 23 years old. They say that one day CGI will be able to replace human actors in almost every motion picture, and after watching "The Thing" it's clear that whenever that happens, it won't be soon enough. The fucking soulless, demonic Tom Hanks golem from "The Polar Express" had more of a back-story than the husks devoured by the alien in "The Thing," which really made it hard for me to care which cast member was going to be eviscerated next.

I will say this: "The Thing" is probably going to do hella well in Japan, simply based on the number of tentacle-related penetrations per second throughout the film's most intense sequences. I suppose American pervs will also enjoy "The Thing," because there's nothing sexier than watching Norwegians die while you standby and do nothing. Well, I guess masturbating isn't "nothing."

To spread the word about this The Thing review on Twitter.

To get instant updates of Mr. Cranky reviews, subscribe to our RSS feed.

Like This The Thing Review? Vote it Up.


Rate This Movie:

Average: 4 (1 vote)

Other Cranky Content You Might Enjoy

  • Naomi Watts was naked in "Mulholland Drive." This was about the only thing that made an otherwise indecipherable film tolerable, though the fact that this moment occurred 1:40:48 into the movie really

  • I think one thing when I see Natasha Henstridge's name atop a marquee, as it is in John Carpenter's "Ghosts of Mars." I think "nudity." I don't think "action," or "high-quality acting" or some such no

  • Special guest reviewer: Mr. Smiley!

    Mr. Smiley's rating:

Carpenter's version had a no name cast except for Kurt Russell

Rajah's picture

 The rest were there just to get killed.

And no I don't think Wilfred Brimley is a big name actor

Personally I prefer the original with James Arness as the monster

James Arness was a monster.

elderly_gentleman's picture

Wasn't he 8 foot 7 or something.

Were he alive today he'd be rolling over in his grave at this disaster.

Mr. Cranky, The original was 1951

TheBigCheese's picture

Mr. Cranky, you must have had a bad day when you wrote this review.  The 1986 movie was itself a remake of the vastly superior 1951 original starring James Arness as a 7 foot tall "thing" that looked like a giant carrot.

The original was a bit talky for my taste

FearlessFreep's picture

But it did have the famous closing line "Keep watching the skies!"


The original was 1951

DrThomasNoisewater's picture

But the remake was of the 1982 version.

Of course we all remember the original story "Who Goes There?"

My favorite episode of Gunsmoke...

Rajah's picture

 The one where ole Matt has Doc and Miss Kitty hanging upside down and he's draining their blood to grow these weird pulsating plants. He has already drained Festus and Chester.

How dare you say that about Bea Arthur!

Rajah's picture

 She sucked dicks not bongs!

Hey folks, howya doin?

TMundo's picture

Another name recognition horror remake.  Pass, pass, thanks to this site.

Well, I occumied Wall street twice, that was pretty interesting, although I didn;t stay there for the day or night or anything.

Any good films out there lately?

Rajah, I like some of the old Outer Limits episodes for old sci-fi/horror.

Then rhere was that whole day of the trifids, invasion of the body snatchers theme.  Killer plants.  Hmmmm, it almost works, but they're still plants, and plants aren't always too scary, unless they are monsters.


RidingFool's picture

You missed Night of the Lepus on TCM.

How about some of those OWS wimmin? Hot or not?

I saw MARGIN CALL yesterday

FearlessFreep's picture

Quite good, with Kevin Spacey in rare form.



gamerarocks's picture

A remake can be good if an effort is put in.  The new one of this drags the others down (too much) just by being associated.  Kurt and Co's Carpenter version was good. 

One out of four people is freakishly stupid. If three of your friends are normal, then it's you.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.