Bomb Rating: 

About 60 minutes of the 110-minute running time of this film involves somebody dropping depth charges on somebody else. So if you're really into big explosions and wide-eyed guys looking up at the ceiling, this film is for you.

The story involves a mission to recover an "Enigma" machine, which would allow the United States to decode German transmissions and move against the Nazis more effectively during World War II. Assigned to this mission are Lt. Andrew Tyler (Matthew McConaughey) and a whole lot of other people who either get shot or blown up when the U.S. submarine goes down and Tyler's crew is forced to man the German sub they've boarded. Since McConaughey is the best-looking of all these people and looks especially good wet, he's left alive to lead the mission.

Whatever happens to the guy who's actually in charge, Coonan (David Keith), is anybody's guess. He probably gets shot, but for all we know David Copperfield makes him disappear. Suddenly, he's just gone. Equally wacky is the captain (Bill Paxton), who teaches Tyler the meaning of sacrifice by waving good-bye as he drowns. Valiant, but it's a lot more likely he'd be screaming "throw me a fucking rope" at the top of his lungs.

After that it's all about depth charges and making the depth charges stop. On board with Tyler are Chief Klough (Harvey Keitel), a bunch of young kids, and the black cook, Eddie (T.C. Carson), who somehow becomes proficient at operating the submarine. Thank God for the United States that everyone aboard this vessel is a crack shot too. The Germans couldn't hit the water if they jumped off the side of the boat, but Tyler and crew could shoot the lapels off a Nazi from 100 paces blindfolded. There's zero character development in this film, and everything else is stolen from "Das Boot." Not exactly what you'd call original filmmaking.

To spread the word about this U-571 review on Twitter.

To get instant updates of Mr. Cranky reviews, subscribe to our RSS feed.

Like This U-571 Review? Vote it Up.


Rate This Movie:

Average: 3 (1 vote)

Other Cranky Content You Might Enjoy

  • Some people dream about being the next "American Idol" or the next Tiger Woods or about growing up and becoming an astronaut. Me? I've always dreamed of being from the "wrong side of the tracks."

  • This film isn't titled "The Boat" for nothing. Though there are people on board the German U-boat that serves as the setting, they're all but irrelevant to the story.

  • I don't know if anyone else would agree, but Liv Tyler looks excessively lumpy to me in this film.